Tino's Artisan Pizza Co. Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The margherita pizza was fresh and really, really good."
• "Ordered Tiramisu as takeout and it was FANTASTIC! The ladyfingers are generously soaked and the taste is rich and delicious."
• "The Tartufo was the star of the show."
• "Everything individually is flavorful which makes every bite delightful."
• "Food is organic and tastes great!"
• "Everything literally everything was fresh and tasty!"
• "All the ingredients were fresh and delicious!"

Cons:

• "But getting a pizza where the dough is not thoroughly cooked through is unfortunately unacceptable."
• "I found the pizza bland and crust not special."
• "The Bruschetta we ordered were horrible! Pizzas were not that great either."
• "Ordered a margarita pie, it was probably the worst pizza I have had in my life."
• "The sauce tasted like jar sauce."
• "The 'focaccia' is actually mediocre toasted bread."
• "The pizza was kind of bland for our liking."

Service

Pros:

• "The inside is super cute with a great and friendly staff!"
• "Our server was very pleasant."
• "Some of the best service in the area, all thanks to Viviana!!"
• "Ashley, our waiter and the manager, could not have been more kind and welcoming."
• "The entire staff is so kind and wonderful."
• "The team was so helpful and attentive to our party’s needs."
• "The staff is very attentive and sweet."

Cons:

• "We never got refills."
• "Everyone around us was desperately seeking service."
• "We waited around an hour to get our bill after finishing our food."
• "Also service was OK but good luck trying to get your waters refilled."
• "There was very less staff to help that too on a Friday night even though barely 4 tables were occupied in the restaurant!"
• "Had to wait for up to 10 mins just to spot a server to ask for a glass of water."
• "There was only 1 server helping out all the guest."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "The place was a gem. Very nice atmosphere."
• "It was very creative..n delicious 😋"
• "The atmosphere is the exact feeling that you want for your local pizza spot."
• "Truly a hidden gem in the Paulus Hook area."
• "Love the vibe of the restaurant, really homey."
• "Really nice little place."
• "It's welcoming, bustling, families around."

Cons:

• "Location: no parking. On the street."
• "Never delivered the food ordered!!!!! THIS PLACE IS A JOKE!"
• "It is a bit small so at times it felt a bit cramped in there because so many people were eager to dine there."
• "The sauce has no taste, taste like a cheap jar sauce."
• "No taste."
• "Mediocre dough topped with mediocre ingredients."
• "It can get a little hot sometimes because of the ovens."

Value

Pros:

• "Pizzas can easily feed 2 people, maybe 3 if appetites aren't huge and you get an antipasto to share."
• "The food will fill you up!"
• "The salad with the purchase of two pizzas made up for it."
• "We shared 2 appetizers and 2 pizzas between 3 people with plenty to take home after."
• "Portions are big for the price."
• "We’ll be prepared with BYOB next time, although the retail wine prices they sell were reasonable, along with reasonable prices all around."
• "Their red sauce is so hearty."

Cons:

• "The price was pretty high."
• "2 pies $39 they are 12 inch pies."
• "Gave me food poisoning!"
• "The biggest downfall was the service, and it wasn't the servers fault!"
• "I did not like the taste of plant based pepproni."
• "The gelato is from Italy and is very good as well."
• "The gnocchi bites were doughy."