Old City Pizza Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The buffalo chicken pizza was just the right amount of spicy and cheesy."
• "Looking for a fantastic, local Philly Cheesesteak? Look no further! They are freshly made, and packed with meat and cheese, hot off the grill!"
• "The pizza was AMAZING! The crust was the perfect mixture of thin and fluffy."
• "The food? Well it was downright FABULOUS!!!"
• "The food tasted great."
• "The food was exceptional; the olive pizza and chicken cheesesteak."
• "Had one of the best cheese steaks I've ever had."

Cons:

• "Our table had pizza and spaghetti. It was all bad. Crust was so tough, couldn’t bite it or cut it."
• "Food was so-so."
• "Fried fish: super frozen - mushy batter - thick breading ( makes it look good but that’s the only edible part of the fish) - sad experience"
• "We all agreed that all the food was very dry in some way or another and that the flavor was almost cooked out of the food."
• "The spaghetti my dad order looked good and he enjoyed it."
• "Horrible cheap pasta ($13), the sauce with mushrooms had no seasoning whatsoever."
• "Pizza sucks."

Service

Pros:

• "The staff was super nice and the pizza came out very perfect."
• "The service is so friendly and prompt."
• "Always great friendly service."
• "Service was attentive and cordial."
• "The service was chill which we enjoyed."
• "Customer Service was great! We were served quickly and with a smile."
• "The person who answers the phone is polite and you can tell they care."

Cons:

• "The one toothed lady working the counter is the rudest."
• "Lady workimg the counter is rude and yelled at a customer."
• "I did not eat here because the staff was rude."
• "The server was not very attentive at all."
• "The old counter woman said very angrily.... 'waitress service only!' Very rude to me."
• "Waitress arrived, we ordered, and waited, waited, waited."
• "Husband, daughter and myself sat down at a table... Sat at the table for more than 15 minutes and didn’t get service except for napkins/utensils."

Value

Pros:

• "You must go for the individual mega-slices of pizza they sell. It is a huge slice of cheese pizza for about $3 which is the best deal you can get."
• "You get what you pay for and a little more!"
• "The prices are reasonable."
• "Not too expensive for how much food you get."
• "For around $3 the pizza slices are huge!!"
• "We got a lot of food for the price we paid."
• "You absolutely 100% get your money's worth with this restaurant."

Cons:

• "Get better food for cheaper."
• "The price for a 10 inch was kind of high."
• "For 3 drinks, 1 refill, 1 10 in pizza and a cheesesteak it cost 30. Not worth it l, we could have gone else where for cheaper."
• "I didn't know even the mayonnaise makes the price more expensive not just the lettuce."
• "I ordered a cheesesteak and onion rings hoping it would be cheaper than bourse food hall and it was trash 🗑 the cheesesteak tasted awful."
• "I ordered a cheesesteak and onion rings hoping it would be cheaper than bourse food hall and it was trash 🗑 the cheesesteak tasted awful and the onion rings were a small portion, the place looked dirty and it was overpriced!"

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "They created a very home like atmosphere."
• "The place was spotless and staff was so polite!!!"
• "It's a beautiful place that instantly felt like home."
• "One block from Wyndham in the historic district."
• "Very quiet and relaxed, like any other neighborhood eatery, but in this case, the location is also very convenient."
• "Lovely quaint little place. I ordered the Western omelette with potatoes and onions."
• "Great food and casual, old-school atmosphere."

Cons:

• "The bathroom was very dirty when I went in there as well."
• "The entire experience was just odd or horrible to say the least."
• "Bathroom super dirty"
• "The restaurant didn't feel clean, and the bathrooms were kind of gross."
• "Floor dirty"
• "The old lady's who run breakfast are slow."

Location

Pros:

• "Stumbled upon this fantastic place."
• "It's right down the road from Betsy Ross house, the Philadelphia Mint, Federal Reserve, Liberty Bell, Independence Hall, and near Penn's Landing."
• "Stopped in on a rainy day after visiting the Betsy Ross House. This place is a GEM!"
• "Would definitely recommend a visit if you are ever in the Historical District of Philadelphia."
• "If you're visiting Philly's historic district, try it!"
• "This place was spacious compared to other pizzerias in the area."

Cons:

• "Like many places this place has no parking, except for the street which is limited."