"What an old school place with great food and service!"
"Have been going to Nancy's Townhouse for over 15 years. Great food, best thin crust pizza ever."
"Crust was paper thin and sauce was flavorful. I’d come back during the week but not on a Friday again."
"The absolute best pizza I've ever had in my entire life."
"Tasty thin-crust pizza with many options."
"Good flavor in the sauce and quality toppings."
"The pizza is absolutely amazing."
Cons:
"The grandma pie came out and did not look like a grandma pie with the piece of fresh mozzarella and basil it look like a normal cheese pie I had to ask if this was the grandma pie."
"The margarita was so bland that no amt of salt, red pepper, or garlic powder helped it."
"The pizza just didn't taste good, to me, unfortunately."
"The margherita pizza had no taste at all the tomato paste lacked salt and the other vital spices."
"It was not as tasty as everybody made it sound the thin crust pizza."
"The pizza was floppy and very thin not good at all."
"The pizza was soggy, and the thin crust crumbled immediately."
Service
Pros:
"The staff is always friendly and hospitable."
"A I’m home ma kinda feeling you get when you get inside the staff on top of things now the food OMG!!! Awesome the pizza amazing service amazing highly recommend."
"The beer and tap selection was very good and the service was excellent."
"The service is always prompt and friendly, simple but efficient."
"Friendly service without fail."
"Service was great and friendly."
"The service was great for to go."
Cons:
"The service was slow."
"Lunchtime seems slower paced possibly due to having fewer wait staff even though business seems good."
"The bartender came up to us and advised that she had other people waiting for the bar seats before us... Just wouldn’t give my business to a place that does that."
"We had reservations for 7:45 we were standing in the cold waiting to be seated the waitress was rude and said we had to wait for people to leave."
"It’s sad to say that I was disappointed when a waitress told me that there was a Half hour wait but sat the people behind us because they were relatives."
"Long wait time with no communication, poor service, cold pizza upon pick-up."
"The service was good but hectic, which is understandable."
Ambiance
Pros:
"Very old school atmosphere which is cool."
"The atmosphere and the place is really nostalgic."
"Its vintage vibe, makes you feel at home."
"Great little hole in the wall place with a dated and enjoyable atmosphere."
"The cozy ambiance adds to the overall delightful dining experience."
"Old school vibe that's hard to find nowadays."
"Authentic, welcoming, and cozy -- a downstairs bar and Italian restaurant complete with red checkered tablecloths."
Cons:
"Classic joint but it could of been a bit cleaner."
"But it's a small basement dining area with no windows. Very dark, dank, and there's a musty odor."
"Outdoor dining needs help from poor lighting junkyard furniture, dirty utensils."
"Very small & tables are hard to come by."
"Dirty/poor cleanliness around bar area, sanitation concerns."
"Their dining room is set up in a way where tables are literally back to back rather than six feet apart."
"You walk into a basement pretty much. They have their tables separated by plastic dividers."
Value
Pros:
"Open since 1944 - can't go wrong here."
"Note that they do charge an additional fee for credit cards which can be avoided by paying cash."
"Parking is stress-free here – no need to worry about fees as there's ample parking available in the back lot."
"Their large plain pie seems like a decent value for a hungry person even before adding toppings!"
"Priced as if it was 2008. This place is a gem."
"The pizza is just incredible but everyone should know that by now!!"
"This place is a must stop! Real old school Italian."
Cons:
"They also need to update the prices on the website so guests aren't confused by the higher bill when they go to pay for their takeout order."
"But for $1.65 for onions on one side I wish they'd put more than a few rings on it."
"Overrated. Pizza Crust is thin no doubt but the wait and the portions don’t equate to reviews especially in comparison to pricing."
"The only thing I wish they had was some sort of wheelchair/ stroller accessibility."
"Parking sucks!!"
"Wonderful thin crust pizza but they tend to burn the edges so there is an inch or two of waste and inedible crust."