The Angelo Pizza Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The pizza was so hot and the ingredients were super fresh."
• "Delicious balance of sauce and cheese; SO good that i brought 2 jars of their homemade sauce home."
• "Crispy crust, tangy garlic flavored sauce with a bit of hot spice."
• "They include a pepper with every pizza and omg ITS TO DIE FOR !"
• "The pizza is seasoned perfectly, and comes with interesting toppings like 'not pepperoni' (the Italian version of pepperoni)."
• "Very good pizza! Had the cheese, was VERY flavorful and a great mix of authentic sauce and cheese."
• "The crust was so crispy and the sauce tasted so fresh."

Cons:

• "Came bit late very dried up, cold!"
• "Personally the pizza wasn’t for me. Was burnt and too crispy. Very oily too."
• "I show up 45 minutes later to two very cold pizzas sitting amongst stacks of others."
• "The pizza was average at best."
• "Crust had no flavor. Crust had a weird simultaneous mix of un-erectness at the point, while having a crunch at the back end."
• "It tasted a bit dull, more saucy and a bit sweet."
• "Unfortunately sometimes they overcook the pizza to reach to a level that it's almost burned."

Service

Pros:

• "Service was fast and friendly and pizza didn't take long to cook."
• "The guy working there was kind and chatted while making our pizza, really making us feel welcome."
• "The staff is helpful and accommodating to people with a vegetarian palate."
• "Service second to none (even gave my 4 yo a small piece of dough to practice ‘tossing’) and awesome atmosphere."
• "Staff was very friendly and helpful."
• "The customer service and overall environment of the place is unmatched."
• "The guys serving were friendly and it was a really nice and chilled environment."

Cons:

• "The pizza is good but the wait is surprisingly long for dining in."
• "Make sure to order ahead, normal wait times are 30 to 45 minutes for a pie."
• "The staff was too busy pounding beers during a football game to get my pizza out in a reasonable time frame."
• "One out of six people behind the counter was wearing a mask, despite a citywide mandate."
• "Both orders were not prepared by the time they were supposed to be and the owner/cook seemed in the weeds."
• "When you tell a customer 20 minutes, and they show up in 20 minutes, and you STILL haven’t started their order, don’t tell them 'it will be right out'."
• "The pizza was cold and looked like it was made at least an hour before pickup."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "The room is clean, friendly and inviting."
• "Not only was the pizza out of this world (phenomenal sauce, perfect crust and seasonings!) but talk about atmosphere!"
• "Family-run joint (s/o to the owner son with employee dad duo, could be a good Netflix original lol)."
• "Everyone in the building was super chill, the place has an overall great vibe."
• "You feel the good vibes luminating through the air."
• "An incredible pizza experience. The environment, the people, and of course, the pizza."
• "The staff is so friendly! Angelo and his father are a great duo."

Cons:

• "I don't get the hype. Perhaps this is the only pizza joint in the neighborhood."
• "I watched the pizza maker wipe his face, and run his hands through his hair, and go right back to slinging dough without washing his hands."
• "Guy behind the counter seemed annoyed when a father and child came in and asked for a pepperoni pie."
• "Don’t be fooled by this mediocre chuckie cheese type pizza."
• "So although this place is a refreshing modern concept it doesn't really deliver on that promise or its cost."
• "Wish they were out faster."

Value

Pros:

• "This pizza is New York Italian approved!"
• "One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had hands down!!!"
• "Our family of 5 polished off 2 18” pizzas, they were that good!"
• "The homemade sauce and the awesome crust make it not only one of the best pizzas in Philadelphia, but one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten!"
• "From bread to sauce to cheese, it deserves every ounce of hype it's gotten and more."
• "Unreal quality, perfect sauce, and high quality ingredients."
• "Their prices are reasonable too."

Cons:

• "Plus buying thru uber eats even with a 30% off total for 1 plain pizza almost $30!"
• "For one you pay $18 for a personal pizza or you can pay an extra two dollars for the “upside down” pizza which is seemingly just cheese first then sauce on top."
• "Prices are too expensive, spent 20$+ tip for a small 12' NOT pepperoni pizza."
• "It's not very consistent but you can get lucky sometimes and get great Philly moody pizza."
• "False advertisement. I’ve been a vegetarian for 9 years. After reading the menu thoroughly I selected ‘the Vinny’. No where did it mention Prosciutto in the sauce."
• "Secondly they don’t deliver but maybe they should because Digiorno is better."