"Servers were all friendly and would definitely go again."
"Service was quick and courteous."
"Really great service, the staff are fabulous!"
Cons:
"Worse service ever received in NYC."
"Sometimes the service could be a little lackluster at being attentive."
"Really DISMAL service for a very expensive experience."
"Service is hit or miss, leaning towards miss."
"Our waiter was so rude and disgusting."
"The service was slow and low quality. We were given dishes and glasses that were dirty or chipped."
"Waiter was AWFUL! Very flippant when he FINALLY came over."
Food Quality
Pros:
"The Meatball Parm and Chicken Parm sandwiches are both finger licking fantastic."
"Today I had the best shrimp scampi over penne that I have had in a very long time thanks to Parm on Vesey."
"The food is tasty."
"Food was scrumptious! Tried a little bit of everything."
"The food here is really good. The portions are large... More than enough food to satisfy you."
"The food is delicious, and the portions are pretty generous."
"Food was great!!"
Cons:
"Definitely not recommended!!"
"I ordered the Chicken Lemon and was extremely disappointed."
"It was three very small pieces of fried chicken parts over a tremendous amount of Cannellini beans and some spaghetti squash... For the price this was extremely disappointing."
"The food was ok. Would not recommend it as the best example of Italian food."
"The food was very ordinary nothing great!!"
"The food was bland and lacking in character."
"The food wasn't the best either and it was definitely overpriced for the quality."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Nice cozy atmosphere. Friendly and easy going staff."
"Their atmosphere calm and presentable."
"Atmosphere cozy, and excellent food."
"It's a nice restaurant, with plenty of space and a pleasant and efficient staff."
"The atmosphere was good and the servers were very friendly."
"The space was larger than expected. It had a cozy and welcoming vibe."
"From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with a warm ambiance that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience."
Cons:
"This place had very weird vibes from the moment you walk in to the moment you sit down."
"It was quite hot indoors."
"Music was so loud you couldn’t hear anyone at our table."
"The place was 75% empty which was frustrating."
"Acoustics are terrible, expect to shout to your tablemates."
"The place was packed and it was painfully loud as if everyone in there was screaming as if it's normal to yell instead of speak."
"Decor is not too exciting."
Value
Pros:
"The tab was $65 which we thought was great considering the generous portions."
"It can be a little pricey, especially for Italian, but you won't feel like you've been shortchanged of a tasty and generously portioned meal."
"Prices are reasonable and it has an old NY vibe inside."
"The Happy Hour deals are unrivaled."
"The total was $16 which was fair because it was tasted fantastic, and each half sandwich made a good meal."
"Def a great value."
"Not only was the portion generous, but it was legitimately one of the best roast beef sandwiches I've had in the area."
Cons:
"The prices are most definitely outrageous for the service that is given and the extreme wait time to get food demonstrates the poor management and lack of thought for the customer."
"It can be a little pricey, especially for Italian."
"The only real downside is that the menu is a tad pricey--expect to spend at least about $18 for a main course."
"The food was pricey but then again being located by the WTC/Brookfield Mall ain't cheap rent."
"The price is a little too high, even by NYC standards."
"The food quality was decent but yeah definitely over priced."
"Menu clearly says 'add prosciutto for $4'. We were charged $15!!"