"The spaghetti was perfectly cooked, al dente, and the meatballs were tender and flavorful."
"The pastas and the tiramisu were fantastic."
"The food seems very fresh and very well prepared with fresh ingredients as well."
"The food here is absolutely delicious - especially if you’re gluten free!!"
Cons:
"Accidentally came here after misremembering the name if Cafe Spaghetti and we were disappointed by the quality of pasta- the cacio e pepe was unlike any we’d ever had… a gelatinous and pretty flavorless sauce."
"This is pasta for Park Slope toddlers. A celebration of mediocre food."
"The star zitti pasta was fresh but really heavy and unsatisfying."
"The food was fatty, and the wine is bottled like in plastic orange juice containers."
"The cost was much too high considering the basic quality of the food."
"The lasagna and spaghetti & meat ball were totally bland."
"The main pasta dish was gross."
Service
Pros:
"And of course, service was stellar!"
"The hostess kindly messaged me to ask for my preference for dinner knowing it was a special occasion."
"The wait staff were friendly and fast, and were flexible about substitutions where possible."
"Last but not least our server, Syd, was such a joy to have."
"Staff is nice and attentive."
"The highly attentive table service."
"Our server, Catherine, was very attentive and we felt very well taken care of."
Cons:
"Service was cursory. Nobody was rude. But it felt like everyone was just trying to get it over with."
"Really confused by this place. Staff was attentive and friendly but for an almost 2 hour wait on a Friday night the food did not deliver."
"Despite having reservations, we were seated in a spot at the back by the kitchen, which was not as nice as the two sides."
"Service was very slow and inattentive."
"Service was inattentive and unhelpful."
"We felt a bit rushed and couldn't quite enjoy ourselves."
"Service was extremely slow, after being seated no one attended to us."
Ambiance
Pros:
"They’ve made it look trendy and instagrammable inside."
"Lovely space and really friendly staff."
"Charm is off the charts and the food is equally good!"
"The atmosphere is super chic, and the pasta-themed mural captures the essence of this lovely spot."
"There’s a vibe that brings you right back to grandma’s house on a Sunday."
"The atmosphere was great."
"The decor and atmosphere are truly beautiful and chic."
Cons:
"No complimentary bread in an Italian restaurant? To go with the pasta? Hmm."
"Rude, inconsiderate, and unfriendly."
"The rest of the tables seemed crowded and a bit loud/chaotic."
"Some of the decorations were a bit tacky - e.g. fake flowers everywhere."
"The chairs were hard and uncomfortable."
"I wish there was more table space."
"The sauces for pasta was overwhelming for the tomato and the broccoli shrimp."
Value
Pros:
"Will definitely leave you wanting to come back to try all their sauces."
"Spent a wonderful afternoon here - highly appreciated ❤️."
"Parking can be a hassle, but if you come on the right time (6-7pm), you should be able to find one right away."
"So good!! Our server Savannah was so helpful and fun."
"Pasta is made fresh along with traditional add on and local in house specialties."
"The whipped ricotta was, and I don’t say this lightly, dynamite."
"The ginger lion cocktail was one of the best I have ever had."
Cons:
"All in all a little pricey for what it is/the pasta dishes."
"The cost was much too high considering the basic quality of the food."
"Considering each suggested add-on is $5 average, it ends up being upwards to $30 for average-mediocre pasta."
"Pasta dishes small. Hubby ordered braised short ribs, $25 and no ribs in the dish."