Osteria Nonnino Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant New York

Address: 637 Hudson St, New York, NY 10014, USA

Phone: +12126253333

Rating: 4.8
based on 153 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The truffle pasta is the BEST I’ve ever had in my life!!"
  • "The pasta is freshly made and has a great chew and texture."
  • "The Fettuccine di Emma and the Paccheri Nonnino with an absolutely phenomenal spicy vodka sauce that very few places make right."
  • "The chicken parm which was a special and was the perfect thickness and a good amount of cheese."
  • "The salmon was cooked perfectly."
  • "The food is absolutely delicious and gets better every time we visit."
  • "The food was DELICIOUS! We had pizza, meatballs, rice balls, meat and cheese plates, and fried calamari with zucchini for our appetizers."

Cons:

  • "Food was terrible. Mushy overcooked broccoli rabe was like baby food."
  • "The trattoria stuffed with short rib and served with a butter sage sauce was severely undercooked and under-seasoned."
  • "Watery pasta; dripping salad, tasteless pizza."
  • "Food was okay, not the best, not the worst. Pasta dish was super hot and overcooked/soggy."
  • "Branzino fried to the dry point and heavily salted."
  • "The bucatini for the cacio e Pepe was overcooked and the sauce was tasteless."
  • "We shared a Caesar salad and a cacio e pepe pizza (also very salty). The pizza was also on the dry side but not bad."

Service

Pros:

  • "Our service provided by Enzo and Daniel could not have been any better."
  • "The servers are attentive and make sure you always have a full glass."
  • "The staff has been very friendly."
  • "The service was impeccable!!"
  • "Our waiter had amazing recommendations and went above and beyond to make sure we were happy with our experience!"
  • "The service was excellent."
  • "Super efficient and attentive service."

Cons:

  • "The only problem is the acoustics are so loud That my ears hurt me there is no insulation in the ceiling so all sounds reverberate and only makes it louder."
  • "Service was way too quick - in and out in 45mins."
  • "The manager or madre D was very rude and uptight."
  • "The service was incredibly slow, about 45 minutes between appetisers and mains."
  • "We waited 40 minutes (and had a reservation), the waiters were not attentive."
  • "Service was a distracted afterthought."
  • "Worse still was that I did leave a 10% of a tip even though it wasn’t worth leaving any and I was told very firmly by a waiter that the tip was too small and that diners 'usually leave more'!"

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere reminded me of a little restaurant in Italy."
  • "The ambiance is warm and inviting, and the service is impeccable."
  • "Great cozy spot in the Meatpacking District, perfect for walking around after."
  • "The atmosphere is lively."
  • "The atmosphere was perfect."
  • "The ambiance is warm and inviting."
  • "Vibes are super cozy and intimate."

Cons:

  • "The only problem is the acoustics are so loud That my ears hurt me there is no insulation in the ceiling so all sounds reverberate and only makes it louder."
  • "Only downside is that it’s a bit crammed and can get loud so a little tough to hear folks."
  • "My fiancé and I went to Osteria Nonnino on a particularly busy night and it was very loud and crowded in the restaurant."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.