Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings Reviews Summary

Service

Pros:

• "Our server Kaitlyn was very attentive and Christa behind the bar made us some fine spirits!"
• "Our service was phenomenal. Our server, Morgan, went above and beyond to make sure we 'got the full experience'."
• "The waitress was very pleasant."
• "The servers are always pleasant and efficient."
• "The staff were beyond pleasant and extremely accommodating!"
• "Our waiter was so helpful and fast."
• "The food and service was outstanding.. the me Alex was so friendly..even Mark the Busby."

Cons:

• "Probably will not go back to try again."
• "It's pretty evident that 'my kind' (black) aren't welcomed or they aren't used to seeing us there often."
• "Our server was non existent. Probably will not go back to try again."
• "The young blond girl who was checking me out at the register was so rude and disrespectful."
• "Great pizza, but our waitress marissa c was horrible."
• "In addition the server was NOT friendly and behaved like she is doing us a favor and seems to be moody."
• "Waitress was OK. Not the best service, not the worse."

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food is amazing and the staff is super friendly and attentive."
• "The classic chicken wings are very well seasoned and good, too!"
• "I've never had meatballs on pizza that tasted this good."
• "Best, most authentic pizza you will find around here."
• "Their eggplant is the best I've ever eaten!"
• "The italian margaritas ho with every item on the menu."
• "The pizza here is absolutely amazing my wife ordered their shrimp scampi pizza and I ordered their Mike's hot honey and burrata pizza and they were the hands down the best pizzas I've ever had in my life."

Cons:

• "Many times before pizza was terrific. Last few times pizza was burnt."
• "Never tf again. First off them wings looks fresh off the bird okay. And thyme stems isn't seasoning."
• "The only disappointment of the evening was the Garlic knots. It arrived at our table cold and dry, which was a bit unexpected."
• "Very unimpressive... the pizza had barely any cheese and loads of tomato sauce."
• "The taste did not meet expectations and on this heavy meat pie the best thing was the meatballs."
• "Ordered Wings cuz we heard they were really good. When we got the wings majority of them were burnt and they offered absolutely no dipping sauces at all wings they come 100% plane so if you don't like clean Wings not a good choice."
• "The blandest pizza I ever had."

Price and Value

Pros:

• "Diddid said Anthony’s is good and he’s willing to pay top dollar for a good pizza."
• "Fair pricing."
• "Definitely got my money's worth."
• "Really flavorful and reasonably priced."
• "Good service, reasonably priced."
• "Love the food, would strongly recommend."
• "Visited this chain for the first time today and thought it was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had."

Cons:

• "Good food, but not good enough to justify the price."
• "The price for the extra toppings it took my small $15 pizza to a small $18 pizza and I pay that for a large with toppings elsewhere."
• "Most of all, way too expensive for both."
• "I paid $60 for one pizza, drink, and 10 wings... for $60 the taste wasn't there."
• "Pizza was less then impressive and very costly."
• "Oh one more thing. .. $34 for one pizza and salad :)"
• "How can you getaway with charging NYC prices in a Wilmington, DE zip code? $6.25 for a draft beer is insane."

Ambiance and Cleanliness

Pros:

• "Very clean. The bathrooms are clean."
• "They have plenty of TVs all around so if you're looking for a nice spot to eat and have some drinks while watching your favorite team play this place is a great choice."
• "Always clean and relaxing setting inside."
• "The restaurant is a simple setup and clean."
• "They expanded their dining area, so open. I love the decor."
• "The atmosphere in this establishment was very comfortable to say the least."
• "Loved the screened in outdoor seating too!"

Cons:

• "Very limited menu. Very tight seating. If you're sitting near the aisle, expect to be bumped by the staff your entire meal without one of them acknowledging that they bumped or elbowed you."
• "Seating is a little cramped in there."
• "We were elbow to elbow and it took an hour for food."
• "The acoustics aren't the best, especially when the place is crowded."
• "It gets a little hard to hear your dining companions when they have live music."
• "The same teenage boy who handled my money went to help the cook... and used his bare hand... to pick up bread from a warming container, placed them in bag to complete my order."
• "The menu is rather small and a tad pricey."

Ordering and Delivery

Pros:

• "I was able to place an order by phone, pay ahead and simply pull up outside to receive my food."
• "Even during COVID, they have been terrific about following mask rules."
• "Restaurant Manager apologized for food quality and gave me a gift certificate."
• "Parking was a bit congested, but we easily found a spot."
• "You can't beat their half off wine bottles on Tuesdays."
• "Samantha made the whole process simple and fast."
• "The prices are reasonable good atmosphere."

Cons:

• "This review is only for their phone-based ordering system. The food is great, and the experience in person is as well, but their computer-based phone ordering system is horrendous and a waste of time."
• "We ordered a pizza and when we arrived the workers had their heads down and were on their phones."
• "Customers beware when ordering a large order... They delivered 10 more pies than we ordered... and charged a delivery fee when I was told it would be waived."
• "The wait in line is 45 minutes even with calling ahead. Then my order was delayed for 45 minutes once curb side person arrived."
• "Ordered pickup for 8pm at 730. 3 entrances with 1 being locked, was very confusing."
• "Timing for curb side service is really awful."
• "1hr 30 mins for pickup... Tried to charge $54 for pizza."