"The pizza here is tasty and they have many topping variations as well!"
"The best woodfired pizza place in entire New York City right in the Broadway theater district."
"They are wood-fired and you can tell the difference immediately upon seeing your food."
"Pizza is wonderful and traditional Neapolitan, made by the skillful hands of a pizzaiola."
"The two pizzas that we had were well made, had good texture, were at the ideal temperature, and above all they tasted fresh."
"Best Gluten free pizza I’ve ever had."
Cons:
"The pizza also tasted truly disgusting and was SO soggy."
"Pizza was not served fresh, was too oily and dough definitely doesn't have any relation with Italy."
"Pizza was greasy and soggy. The one we had was completely weird in taste with that smoked mozzarella, the other pizza tasted like nothing."
"Ordered a margarita pizza, that came saggy in middle and over cooked on the sides."
"The food was awful. The cheese wasn't even melted on the pizza. The cheese and the pizza were cold."
"The pizza has very little cheese on it even though the dough is good quality."
"The crust was thicker and greasier than I like."
Service
Pros:
"Hands down the best restaurant we visited while vacationing in New York! While the food was absolutely amazing, it was the service that truly made me appreciate this place."
"The staff did a great job explaining the menu and being always on our table when we need it."
"The service was prompt and excellent."
"Service was fast and friendly."
"Service was attentive, quick, and professional. Thank you!"
"Staff was super friendly and service really quick!"
"The service was also very good, super friendly!"
Cons:
"The lights kept slightly flickering which was very distracting for me."
"On a side note the amount of fruit flies at the bar warrants a health violation, they were a constant annoying presence over my pizza and drinks."
"Manager never said sorry or came to table again. Very disappointing as looked forward to our experience here."
"Service was horrible, our waitress was talking to her colleague all the time and was ignoring us."
"Service was a bit slow, but it was saturday night."
"Service was slowish."
"The waitress wasn't very attentive."
Price
Pros:
"Very reasonable prices."
"Value here!"
"Cheaper than expected for that quality."
"The food was delicious. And it was reasonably priced and affordable."
"Overall they used high quality ingredients for a fair price."
Cons:
"Dinner for 3 ended up being $220."
"The personal pizzas we got were $26, this place is a total rip off!!"
"Okay pizza... overpriced."
"Wine is overpriced."
"But I give 4 because of the insane price for the pizza - in Italy I would pay 8-9 dollars for the same thing, but here it is 20+ dollars."
"The food was amazing, but very pricey."
"I felt it was a bit expensive for what it was but I think this was mainly down to the exchange rate."
Ambience
Pros:
"Quiet pizza spot with a front door that you really need to push to open."
"The whole place had a great atmosphere."
"It’s also very nice inside!"
"The atmosphere, which seemed lively albeit quite crowded."
"Cozy atmosphere, good soft music, friendly and attentive staff, and superb food!"
"The restaurant is quite small and quaint, which made a nice respite from hectic Times Square."
"Plus, the interior is cozy as hell with friendly staff."
Cons:
"It was impossible to hear each other inside the restaurant it was way too loud."
"Very loud and pretty crammed."
"The seating (too little space for privacy). We were literally seating next to another two tables."
"Seating is tight. Be prepared to sit very close to your neighbor."
"It's the sardine-can lay out-- the tables are so close they have to slide them in and out so that the person sitting against the wall can get to their seat."