Joe's Pizza Reviews Summary

Price

Pros:

• "Price is good, as low as $3.5 per slice (cheese only)."
• "No-nonsense slices for a fair price."
• "Reasonable $’s. Worth the trip over other local N.Y. pizza."

Cons:

• "Price for regular slice is too high compare to other pizza stores."
• "Overpriced slices that cost $4 with toppings, sauce tasted waaaaaay to sweet."
• "Too expensive for any slice of pizza....$3.50 for any slice & $3 for a can of soda."
• "It was $4 which is definitely expensive for a slice."
• "Not the most affordable pies, either."
• "I just wish the prices would go down a bit since they don’t offer rewards and it’s kinda on the pricy side if your a pizza junkie like myself ;)"

Quality

Pros:

• "The pizza tasted amazing. It was warm because it was served just out of the ovens."
• "I really don't know how they are able to make such a damn good slice of pizza. Good crust, good ingredients."
• "The quality of the slices was fantastic."
• "Excellent pizza, period. Large slices, you'd be hard pressed to find better authentic New York pizza anywhere else."
• "The pizza was fresh, tasty and I liked that the dough was not soft or too thick!"
• "One of the best slices of cheese pizza that I've ever had in my entire life."
• "Delicious pizza…great crispy base and very little grease."

Cons:

• "Day by day the quality is going down and down. The dough smells really old stuff."
• "The past 3 pies I’ve ordered have been super undercooked and smashed in the box."
• "The Pizza Was Flat, Crunchy And Had No Taste."
• "Pie was lacking the crunch and airiness you’d get when ordering at the source."
• "Not only was the pizza dry but it wasn’t classy at all 😂."
• "The cheese slice I had was inedible."
• "A crust that had the flavor and texture of cardboard, cheese that had the flavor of, well, nothing."

Service

Pros:

• "Service was fast, even though there were lots waiting for their order."
• "Eat it fresh and while the slices are still hot! Frequent customer and grateful I live nearby!"
• "Don’t be intimidated by the line, it moves fairly quickly."
• "Staff dealt with the late night drunks just fine and kept things orderly."
• "Quick service and great quality. Highly recommended."
• "Friendly guys behind the counter. Fast service."
• "Service is always friendly no matter the hour."

Cons:

• "Also, had a weird experience with the person at cash."
• "I went in and the staff at the counter was arguing with a Doordash employee over a hot bag."
• "The staff is attentive but not cordial."
• "The pizza was decent. Customer service was horrible."
• "This place is chaotic. It’s a pizza JOINT not a restaurant. So be prepared to rub elbows."
• "It's often overcrowded. And even when it's not, the staff isn't super helpful."
• "The pizza itself is fine. The customer service is not."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "The main selling point is availability they are open late in the heart of Williamsburg."
• "It is a great spot for a phenomenal slice!"
• "A piece of NYC celebrity landmarks. The walls are adorned with photos of celebs visiting Joe's, also with currencies from around the world."
• "Great classic slices, friendly staff, and casual atmosphere."
• "Joe's Pizza is a NYC staple!"
• "This place has a unique charm, highlighted by the walls adorned with photos of Hollywood stars enjoying their pizza."
• "Joe's Pizzas in Williamsburg offers a delightful blend of traditional New York-style pizza with modern twists."

Cons:

• "The slices here are great to be sure, but there’s an 'X' factor that the original had that may never be recaptured as the franchise expands."
• "After that, we could finally sit outside on their dirty patio with half the tables having no chairs."
• "You can't really seat over there tho, and since its popular the service is kinda rushed."
• "The restaurant is small and is suited for grab and go. Not much space for family dining."
• "Not a place to sit down in and enjoy your pizza. It's just too packed with people in and out getting pizza."