"The service was quick, the food was delicious and the ambiance was absolutely beautiful!"
"Everything I've eaten here has been good, drinks are excellent and the service is friendly."
"Great service drinks and food!"
"Food was tasty and service was great!"
"The service here is very attentive and took our orders."
"Service was friendly and efficient."
Cons:
"The only very minor complaint would be the service."
"Service didn’t even look at us to see what’s wrong!"
"We gave less than 15% tip and were persistently lectured by the server that 15% is the absolute minimum…"
"Then suddenly another server came and gave extremely aggressive attitude chastising us for placing the order with the previous server who asked us in the first place."
"The service was totally lacking, while there were multiple employees having a chit chat."
"The server did not come by once to ask how things were etc."
"The service was also non existent."
Location & Ambiance
Pros:
"Located in an old church will have your neck sore looking up at the gorgeous ceiling."
"It is located in the theatre district in Manhattan!"
"Great location if you’re hungry after a broadway show."
"The converted church is awesome with a beautiful stained glass skylight."
"Awesome location in a old church."
"The building and the ceiling is gorgeous."
"The interiors are of a former church gives a very antique and unique vibe to this whole place."
Cons:
"The restaurant was cool, but it was darker inside than out."
"For some may be an issue they don’t do free refills on sodas."
"You could tell because we never got refills on our drinks."
"The atmosphere is nice, they have wood ovens so it gets a little hot."
"I suppose the dome only looks good during the day due to the sunlight, when we visited, it had zero lighting."
"The communal seating arrangement adds a communal, family-friendly vibe to the dining experience, making it suitable for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings."
"The restaurant had no music playing and looked pretty dull and sad during dinner."
Food Quality
Pros:
"The pizza was loaded with toppings and was very hot."
"The salad was phenomenal. Perhaps one of the best salads ever had."
"The toppings are fresh and generously applied, making each slice a delightful experience for pizza enthusiasts."
"John’s Vodka Sauce is absolutely amazing!!!"
"The pizza was so good too. Very fresh ingredients and very flavorful."
"The pizza marinara was flavorful and the basil leaves elevated the pizza to a whole nother level—it tasted so fresh."
"The pizza was very very good. Love the lightly char crust and flavorful sauce."
Cons:
"There are other places nearby that don’t charge you 50$ (we paid 100$ for 2 pizzas) for a butter pizza with cheese."
"Pizza looks delicious, doesn't taste great."
"Pizza crust is dry and ingredients don’t seem to be of great quality."
"The fried calamari is well cooked. However, I missed some flavor to taste but it was saved by the sauce."
"For some may be an issue they don’t do free refills on sodas."
"The pizza had the right amount of sauce and cheese. The crust was thin and crunchy."
"The pizza though was excellent. Crispy at the crust and chewy towards the point."