Ikaros Diner Reviews Summary

Category: Diner

Address: 909 Union Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA

Phone: +18455672600

Rating: 4.1
based on 175 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food was tasty and hot."
  • "They bake all their bread (delicious) and desserts on site."
  • "The Avgolemono soup was delicious, and the gyro was tasty, if a little dry."
  • "Wonderful homemade food, huge menu, friendly wait staff!! The spanakopita, souvlaki, and chicken salad club sandwiches were delicious."
  • "The food was perfect. Fluffy and delicious pancakes, French toast and eggs."
  • "The steak was cut in half, cooked exactly the way I asked and it filled the plate, with sauteed mushrooms piled on top, cooked to perfection."
  • "Each dish was absolutely amazing! The pancakes were fluffy and the healthy wrap and eggs Benedict were cooked to perfection."

Cons:

  • "The food was inconsistent."
  • "The food!!! How bad can your omelette be? It was greasy, tasteless."
  • "The sweet potato fries were really quite bland and maybe even undercooked."
  • "I ordered the shrimp scampi over rice. I might'st well have ordered straight fish. It tasted like fish from a polluted water source."
  • "However the clam chowder was inedible, it tasted like the cook dumped a bucket of salt into the pot."
  • "All the food came out extremely over cooked."
  • "The chicken salad sandwich had no flavor."

Service

Pros:

  • "Service is awesome and always feel taken care of by staff. Very attentive."
  • "They are very friendly."
  • "The service was outstanding."
  • "Service was wonderful and all staff friendly."
  • "Service was consistent never even waited for a refill."
  • "Servers are always friendly."
  • "Very friendly prompt service."

Cons:

  • "We never go seated. We had to sit ourselves. Waitress was horrible."
  • "Another customer came in, sat himself and walked out after 15 min of no one coming to his table."
  • "The wait staff were arguing with each other very loud as well."
  • "Extremely slow service."
  • "It was freezing cold in there and the waitress said that they keep getting it repaired but that it never really gets fixed."
  • "Service was not as expected - not very friendly or attentive and manners gone by the wayside."
  • "We walked in and were ignored briefly before being curtly and unapologetically told to sit down at a booth right next to the entrance."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "Looks like a neat old time diner."
  • "Attractive, clean and comfortable decor."
  • "It definitely has that old diner feel, as soon as you walk in the staff was friendly and talked to you like you’ve been there 100 times."
  • "This is a very cute diner."
  • "Ikaros Diner is a nice diner that is reminiscent of the trolley diners of the past."
  • "It's a very nice modern restaurant."
  • "From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with friendly smiles and a welcoming atmosphere that set the tone for a fantastic meal."

Cons:

  • "For a diner. I wasn't really impressed."
  • "It is showing signs of wear. It also needed a good cleaning. There was a section of ceiling removed due to a leak."
  • "The interior could use a bit of cleaning and freshening up. It has an overall apocalyptic quality inside."
  • "Place was messy/dreary looking. Booths were worn."
  • "The condition of the diner could use some work. It is showing signs of wear."
  • "Tables were sticky and unsanitary I do not recommend this place at all."
  • "The diner has seen better days to be honest."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.