Joe & Pat's Pizzeria & Restaurant Reviews Summary

Pizza Quality

Pros:

• "Our mushroom and pepperoni pizza was cooked perfectly, and we consider the pizza the best we have ever eaten."
• "The slices were light, so I didn't feel bloated even after 3 slices."
• "The crust is thin, but not too thin. Crispy and fresh."
• "The pizza has super thin crust and is delicious."
• "The pizza is my favorite. It's a super thin, crispy crust with a really tasty sauce."
• "The thin crust pizza is so good here!"
• "This is the best pizza, period."

Cons:

• "I do not like the look or taste of theirs. It taste like a can pasta sauce."
• "The pie crust was burnt charcoal black."
• "The pizza being so thin, a party of 3 needed 2 large pies, but we only had time for 1."
• "The pizza tasted ok, mediocre at best, but nothing spectacular."
• "Not good pizza. Thinner than matzoh, not much flavor or cheese."
• "The pizza is really thin, and the crust is usually burnt."
• "The crust is so extremely thin that it ended up just being flimsy and soggy."

Service

Pros:

• "Super friendly and professional staff."
• "Server was very attentive through the duration of our meal."
• "Host and waitresses are friendly and have good knowledge of the menu."
• "The staff at Joe and Pat’s are very accommodating."
• "Service was great, greeted me & the boys with a welcoming energy."
• "Great people and great service."
• "Great service with a smile."

Cons:

• "The service was not very good even though we ordered two pizzas basically our waitress drop off the pizzas and we did not see her the rest of the time except for the check."
• "But some guy standing by the kitchen door was quite unpleasant(assuming it was the manager as previous reviews have stated)."
• "Not happy with the customer service."
• "On top of the disappointing pizza the service was non existent maybe everyone was too busy waiting on the Impractical Joker who was dining there."
• "Paid cash and the owner came to table and said in a nasty tone that the $10 bill we gave as a tip was to nasty looking and the bank would refuse to take it...Very nasty way to treat customers who frequently go to the restaurant."
• "i call to check the status and the lady who answer the phone was laughing and hang me up very disrespectful and horrible pizza."
• "Terrible customer service and attitude from the current 'manager,' handling a pizza mistake they made."

Price

Pros:

• "if you go Monday or Tuesday it's $12 pies if you take out."
• "Currently they offer a Mon-Tue Special: $10 Large Pie (take out only). Can't beat that!"
• "The $10 to go pizza on Monday and Tuesday is also a fantastic deal, cheaper than even mediocre pie elsewhere."
• "There is a Monday and Tuesday special for a plain cheese pizza for 11 dollars."
• "Great prices too!!!"
• "I found the wine & beer prices to be very good here."
• "Solid pizza. Consistent and quick delivery."

Cons:

• "It's a bit pricey but worth it if you want great pizza from a place that has been around forever."
• "Prize is quite pricey. 3.50 for a slice of pizza as thin as a sheet of paper totally not worth it."
• "Way OVERPRICED."
• "Ended up paying over $50, which is insanity for how below average the pizza was."
• "Not cheap. $16 for a regular pie most local places are $9-$10 especially a thin crust."
• "Little on the pricey side."
• "Totally NOT worth the $13 each."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Joe and Pats is a classic Staten Island establishment."
• "Very lovely experience me and my partner had while visiting this location. Interior is beautiful and very intimate."
• "The atmosphere is very good."
• "Lighting is not bright but its calming."
• "The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, with friendly staff and a laid-back vibe."
• "The decor is laid back & chill with couches & tables."
• "The back dining room is beautifully painted with columns, flowers, clouds, etc. all over the walls."

Cons:

• "The place is overrun with teens."
• "Having to sit down and be waited on will aaaalways drag things out and make it more difficult to squeeze things in."
• "It sometimes has a very bad odor in the restaurant."
• "it was very bad smell in the dining area that lingered everywhere and they used scented candles to cover the smell (which made it worse)."
• "I just walked into the restaurant with my son to get a table and there was a TERRIBLE odor the minute you opened the door it smelled like a Porto-potty."