Carroll Place Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant New York

Address: 157 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012, USA

Phone: +12122601700

Rating: 4.3
based on 246 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "All of their pizzas are a hit."
  • "The rice balls and chicken tenders are really good for apps."
  • "The truffle fries were bomb."
  • "Great atmosphere and food (especially the orecchiette with pesto and sausage!!!)."
  • "The pizza was phenomenal, & those rosemary wings baybee! Delicious!"
  • "The eggs benedict was perfectly cooked and the fries were so good."
  • "The food is amazing."

Cons:

  • "The eggs benny were a little disappointing as the eggs were overdone."
  • "The pizza was ok and the mimosas were not good."
  • "We also never got half the food we ordered after over an hour and a half, so a few of us left hungry."
  • "The penne alla vodka lacked a decent amount of sauce for me."
  • "We had the burgers and they were dry."
  • "The chicken was kind of dry but okay."
  • "The two vegetables on my roasted chicken dinner plate tasted like they had been cooked in a pan where something had been burned."

Service

Pros:

  • "They made sure we never waited to fill our glasses."
  • "We had the best server Kayla who was energetic and helpful with our order."
  • "Service was friendly and awesome staff, kudos to Cayla!"
  • "The staff provided the most unbelievably welcoming service."
  • "The service was also spectacular."
  • "Staff was friendly and very attentive."
  • "Cathrine was the best waitress! We can’t wait to go back and hopefully see her again! Thank you Catherine for the excellent service!"

Cons:

  • "Despite all the issues, no one made an attempt to do anything about it."
  • "Incredibly rude staff member!! he was wearing a red hat last night and so disrespectful."
  • "The service was excruciatingly slow and inattentive."
  • "After less than two hours at our table, we were very rudely and abruptly told that we need to leave the table immediately because a party needs our table."
  • "Unfortunately our server was not only unfriendly but was also very unhelpful our entire visit."
  • "Staff are scam artists. Bartender tried to overcharge us for drinks."
  • "Service was horrible. Waitresses were super snobby and standoffish."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Nice atmosphere/decor, although very crowded and loud."
  • "Gorgeous location. Decor is cool, ambiance is nice."
  • "The restaurant has two levels, the decor is 'rustic-chic' and the scene is young, but not trashy."
  • "The atmosphere as soon as you walk in is very calm and inviting."
  • "Great atmosphere."
  • "The vibe is amazing!"
  • "The inside was spectacular with a Great Gatsby vibe."

Cons:

  • "The tables for couples are so small, we were squished in between a couple of 4-top tables."
  • "The seating is a little too close for comfort."
  • "Small space in between tables after 4 min of sitting waiters/servers were already grazing past me."
  • "The place is loud, with a DJ and fun music."
  • "They had music blasting sooo loud you couldn't hear yourself think let alone talk to your table."
  • "The restaurant is far too noisy, you can't even hear the person across from you sitting at a dollhouse-sized table."
  • "Music was ok, smelled like sweat on the first floor because people were dancing."

Value

Pros:

  • "Its one of the better brunch deals at $28, inclusive of the entree and for an hour and a half of bottomless drinks."
  • "They have a great $25 deal that gets you unlimited brunch drinks and an entree."
  • "The prices are quite reasonable, most portions are very large."
  • "The check ended up being very reasonable."
  • "Beer is reasonably priced."
  • "For all the food and drinks you get with this deal, I think it was fairly priced."
  • "At just $27 for an entree and a bottomless amount of any brunch drink, Carroll Place is a bargain."

Cons:

  • "The bartender charged 77 dollars.i think overpriced a lot.was shocked."
  • "We got only two plates of each dish for 9 people and when asked more were told its extra charge."
  • "So we asked for 4 shots peach schnapps, to give it some flavor and they charged us an extra $40."
  • "Super overpriced drinks…$20 for a single green tea shot and tip is automatically included."
  • "The food for $85 per person was trash."
  • "A few items on the menu cost extra so the bill ended up being 58$ per person which felt really less for the quantity and quality of 3 course meal, bottomless mimosa and sangria that was served to us."
  • "They still have their vegan menu up on their website, so I went in thinking they had decent vegan options. I came in already disappointed."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.