"Got the grilled tuna wrap, shrimp salad wrap, lobster salad wrap, and flounder sandwich....all of it exceptionally good!"
"Very good portions and very fresh tasting seafood joint not too far from the shore."
"Had the fried oyster and heard they were the best; and I agree."
"We got the Clam Pot, which was a delicious feast."
"Food was fresh, and generous portions!"
"The food was delicious, perfectly cooked and the wait staff was friendly."
"Food was excellent. We had mussels in garlic sauce and fried calamari."
Cons:
"What the H is the coating (?) even made of that it doesn't have any flavor at all?"
"Food was absolutely bland as could be."
"The New England Clam Chowder was disappointing as it seemed to just be potatoes in the creamy broth."
"The crab cakes had a lot of shells."
"The stuffed flounder was way overcooked and dry."
"Calamari was fried in old oil and tasted like French fries."
"Stuffed shrimp tasted like nothing."
Service
Pros:
"Fernando our waiter was attentive and gave outstanding service."
"Service was very good."
"Everyone was wonderful..the waitress was amazing..and the food was the best ever."
"The food and the service were great."
"Our waitress was Chelsea, she was very nice, very friendly, very attentive to us."
"Service was excellent...friendly, knowledgeable and attentive."
"Lauren, our server, rocked throughout lunch service on this Tuesday in mid August."
Cons:
"I also noticed that all the black people were seated in the corners of the restaurant tucked away which made me realize why we were even put way in the corner and it explained their attitude."
"When the waitress came to our table we asked her if we can change to a booth. Five minutes later the hostess comes back with an attitude snatched the menus off the table and said nothing."
"Every time we asked her for something she had an attitude like she didn’t want to do it."
"Our waitress disappeared on us multiple times and for significant lengths of time."
"It seemed as if the staff did not have any sense of urgency."
"The staff should be coached on how to handle situations like this."
"Server never refilled drinks, did not ask how food was until my partner was finished eating."
Ambiance
Pros:
"It’s very minimalistic on the inside. They don’t have a ton of interior decor, but they added enough of a touch to make the place a pleasant setting."
"Great atmosphere... Clean clean clean."
"BYOB allowed me to bring my favorite wine to compliment my meal 😊"
"Cute open atmosphere."
"The inside is spacious, urban and clean."
"The new place is beautiful too!!"
"Great atmosphere. Beautiful inside."
Cons:
"The new setup felt cavernous and cold compared to the former cozier layout."
"The atmosphere is a bit noisier because of the large room."
"The place was like a daycare people joking around the entire time."
"However, the bright lights ruin any ambiance, and voices of the guests seated around us carry so as to make conversation difficult."
"The dining room is all hard surfaces and very noisy."
"The place is very loud."
"It can get loud when they are busy because the noise echos with the high ceilings."
Value
Pros:
"For cheaper fish like flounder, on the other hand, I feel I get a lot of bang for my buck."
"It is Seafood so it's not cheap. However prices are fair."
"The prices are very reasonable and the portions are generous."
"Their prices are much more reasonable than most fish restaurants in Belmar for standard fare."
"You get what you pay for, so it's worth it."
"Their pricing is very, very reasonable, especially considering the freshness and quality."
"The food is awesome and fairly priced."
Cons:
"We will not go back as the prices were not fair for what you you received on the plate."
"Very pricy for NO NO NO reason at all."
"While it was edible it was very over priced."
"Overpriced for quality and portion size."
"For $200 for five people (we did not get apps or soup) we will spend our money elsewhere."
"The prices were not fair for what you you received on the plate."
"The menu is a bit pricey (but hey, it's seafood)."