Citrus Restaurant Reviews Summary

Category: Indian restaurant

Address: NY, 1004 NY-94, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA

Phone: +18457874947

Rating: 4.6
based on 256 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The nuances in the flavors were spectacular."
  • "The food was absolutely amazing, appetizers and entrees!"
  • "Everything is so fresh and delicious."
  • "Their dishes are consistently well prepared, the vegetables are always crisp."
  • "Every dish I tried was a delightful explosion of flavors."
  • "The food here is fresh, authentic, and homey."
  • "The food is always fresh and delicious!"

Cons:

  • "The flavors were off."
  • "The food is okay. Drinks are like colored salt water. Soup taste like a flavored detergent."
  • "The food could be seasoned better; there's no difference between medium spice and spicy. It is just bland."
  • "The Rogan Josh was undercooked and the meat was very tough to chew."
  • "The butter chicken did not inspire the taste buds either."
  • "This was the blandest Indian food that I ever had."
  • "The food was nowhere close to authentic Indian."

Service

Pros:

  • "They took my call early, delivered early and gave our family an incredibly flavorable dinner that is hard to come by right now."
  • "Highly recommend. I will definitely come back again not only for the delicious food but the amazing service."
  • "The service was wonderful and the food was delicious."
  • "Service is excellent - very attentive to our needs even when packed."
  • "Staff are very pleasant and attentive; ensuring a pleasurable dining experience."
  • "The staff is very attentive and personable."
  • "The service is excellent and very attentive."

Cons:

  • "We were ignored by the wait staff."
  • "Service is consistently poor if you dine alone."
  • "Our first server was rude and kept arguing with us."
  • "Ultimately, after the poor service, I wouldn't return."
  • "A guy who says he is a manger is not fit for the job. He disrespects his customers."
  • "Even getting the check took 15 minutes first time around."
  • "Worst service I have ever experienced in a sit down restaurant."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The ambiance was very warm and cozy."
  • "The atmosphere is warm and inviting."
  • "Has an upscale feel."
  • "Nice atmosphere, friendly and fast service, and full bar."
  • "The atmosphere is serene."
  • "Decor inside is attractive."
  • "The atmosphere is delicately crafted for an excellent dinner or lunch experience."

Cons:

  • "The place is under construction and looks abandoned on the outside."
  • "The parking lot is due for some maintenance, watch out for the potholes!"
  • "The parking lot looked awful with potholes."
  • "The front entrance was horrible with water draining from the ceiling and flooded."
  • "The place is in shambles and looks like a dirty mess."
  • "Also they had the air conditioner on full blast, we left with a head ache sitting in the cold air hitting us directly from the vents constantly."
  • "Oh and side note...the roof was leaking on us all night too."

Value

Pros:

  • "For the price, you are getting way more than what you're paying for."
  • "Prices and location good, service is excellent."
  • "Pricing is reasonable."
  • "The prices are very affordable (~$10-15 per entree, with exceptions); even the most hungry appetite will very likely be satiated with a single entree."
  • "Reasonable prices for an upscale like restaurant."
  • "Prices are reasonable!"
  • "We got all of this food for $13.99 (plus tax and tip of course)."

Cons:

  • "The pricing was a bit much but it was worth it."
  • "Unfortunately there is a trend in food, where Vegetable dishes are the same price as those with meat."
  • "Seventy dollars for two buffets and a cup of chai was a bit high even after the increased prices brought on by the pandemic."
  • "This order was close to 80.00! What happened to Indian food being on the economical side?"
  • "It's a bit pricey because of the location near New York City."
  • "They charge prices that rival high price restaurants."
  • "The weekend buffet for $18pp without tax is quite expensive for the spread offered."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.