Angeloni's Restaurant and Pizzeria Reviews Summary

Pizza Quality

Pros:

• "The pizza went from amazing to very good."
• "Delicious pizza. Our party really enjoyed their thin crust pie."
• "The nicest people! The most amazing pizza! All in a beautiful setting."
• "The pizza I had there me and my family was excellent the Caesar salad so the fresh mozzarella and sliced tomato."
• "Got the thinny thin crust half plain half buffalo chicken and it was everything i hoped it would be so flavorful and crunchy."
• "Their pizza is incredible and the dinner was Very good as usual."
• "The pizza is amazing and the thinny-thin is actually thin and crispy!"

Cons:

• "This place has always been overpriced, but it used to be worth it."
• "We ordered a simple pizza this evening. Pizza sucked sadly."
• "One of our three pizzas came out wrong."
• "Small thin pizza that doesn't have much taste and is overpriced."
• "Another one of the pizzas was extremely dry and lacked flavor."
• "This pizza was waaaaaay overcooked. All you could pretty much taste is burnt trust."
• "Ordered the 'thinny thin' - it was very dry and hard to chew. Inedible overcooked pizza."

Restaurant Atmosphere

Pros:

• "This cozy restaurant, located right off downtown Caldwell’s Bloomfield Ave strip, serves delicious pizzeria classics."
• "Food was delicious, had a nice old school pizzaria vibe and was spacious."
• "Great thin crust pizza. Wonderful atmosphere."
• "The Atmosphere, Food, and Staff were all EXCEPTIONAL!!!"
• "When I came, the restaurant was not busy and has a fun, yet clean, pizzeria atmosphere."
• "The restaurant itself is decorated beautifully, and the service was fast and in point."
• "Pretty cool ambiance inside and good service too!"

Cons:

• "DO NOT EAT HERE. service was horrible, food was ok at best."
• "The tables were sticky and smelled like damp rotten towels."
• "Parking is also horrible... Go somewhere else if you want pizza..."
• "Warning: the place is very, very loud inside."
• "They initially sat us down in the darkest unlit side of a empty dining hall - when we tried to move to a different table the waitress wouldn’t let us for some odd reason."
• "Lights were a bit too dim for this Senior Citizen."
• "This place is very crowded and the dining area is very loud."

Service

Pros:

• "They are kind and friendly. The staff are well mannered."
• "Service and staff very nice."
• "Our servers were fantastic."
• "Service was excellent, with our server and various other employees checkin in on us periodically, but not so frequently that we were harassed."
• "Service was great! And my tip showed it."
• "Our server was Jacob and he made the night out very enjoyable."
• "Service was excellent."

Cons:

• "we’ve ordered from here a few months ago and remembered liking it a lot, so last night we decided to order the exact same two dishes and within a few hours both my husband and I clearly got food poisoning!!"
• "I wouldn't recommend ordering lunch delivery orders unless you can wait for 90 minutes or more."
• "I Ordered a Pizza on 5/12/22 at 7:44pm and was quoted at 45 minutes. At 9:09 I called, as no delivery yet."
• "Service was a bit slow and it wasn't too busy at the time."
• "The food was decent but we got kicked out after being there for an hour and a half."
• "The service was not the friendliest throughout the meal and it was very slow."
• "The young kid that served us should not be a waiter until he is properly trained on how to greet people and be polite."

Value

Pros:

• "Prices are not bad."
• "BYOB allows you to enjoy your favorite wine with the delicious food."
• "You definitely are getting what you pay for. Good quality pizza."
• "They also offer mini portions of pasta so that you can try a few things."
• "Their garlic knots are great too."
• "Love that they serve garlic knots with their bread platter!"
• "Kids can make their own personal pie with toppings of their choice."

Cons:

• "Foods good it’s just way too expensive $20 for pasta!? No thank you, when the prices were lower it was great but now you can’t feed a family of 4 unless you want to take out a $5,000 loan seriously!"
• "The cost was very high for what we got."
• "A side order of French fries are $14 a salad is $20... Food was mediocre at best."
• "Pizza arrived 90 minutes after ordering, ice cold, hard as a rock and completely inedible."
• "I had the margarita pie. It wasn't good."
• "Place was overpriced as it was now cause of 'inflation', it sky rocketed!"
• "We strongly dislike the $40 minimum for delivery to Fairfield."