Magic Hour Rooftop Bar & Lounge Reviews Summary

Ambiance

Pros:

• "The rooftop view was absolutely gorgeous."
• "This place gives off such a cool vibe! The decor and music was awesome."
• "The ambiance is very cool, starting with the maze to get to the elevator."
• "The vibes amazing. The fun house entrance with lovely rose decorations with city skylines, an adult garden with a carousel that spins. Each dining area is beautiful, the bar is full of life."
• "The ambiance and NY views are fenomenal."
• "This is a very picture worthy location and it definitely screams NYC."
• "A Hip, upscale luxury rooftop bar with elegant garden vibes."

Cons:

• "The only downfall was the menu."
• "The line snakes like a quest, only to reveal a view obscured by artificial flora and selfie-seeking staff and patrons."
• "If you’re going for the Instagrammable photo spots, you’ll probably be disappointed as they’re only seasonal."
• "Wasn't really a Thursday night we are on a rooftop having a good time vibe."
• "We were disappointed that we weren't allowed to go see the carousel."
• "Single women beware: unless you have a man to speak for you, don't go - it's not a safe place for women."
• "The view from our table wasn’t the best because they’ve enclosed the rooftop area and have tall walls and a roof over most of it."

Service

Pros:

• "Our server, elevator person, bouncer, and door staff on the street were each incredibly friendly."
• "The service is great, attentive and pleasant."
• "The ladies and I very much enjoyed our food and drinks."
• "Service was good, everyone was friendly and attentive."
• "The service was great--we were able to walk in without a reservation and still get a table."
• "Staff was friendly and attentive."
• "Service was great from security outside to the hosts and waiters."

Cons:

• "Terrible service. I've never had to try and flag down the waitress or staff so much."
• "Our server took our drink orders 30 minutes after we were seated at our table."
• "Our waitress seemed like she didn’t want to be there also just saw a lot of employees using their phones."
• "We had to wait a very long time. We were trying to get attention of the staff but our server basically didn’t see us!"
• "The service wasn't that great."
• "The service from our waiter was VERY SLOW."
• "The service once we got there for brunch was poor."

Food & Drinks

Pros:

• "The drinks are tasty and seem to be getting better every time I come."
• "The food was fantastic."
• "Food was creative and delicious."
• "We ordered truffle fries and Tacos with guacamole which went very well with the drinks."
• "The food was amazing for brunch!"
• "The drinks were yummy and reasonably priced for such a nice place!"
• "The food and atmosphere was amazing."

Cons:

• "They serve all drinks and cocktails in cheap plastic cups, and the plates are plastic too."
• "The signature red velvet pancakes with cotton candy was just regular pancakes with red food coloring and cotton candy on top."
• "The grilled chicken in the ceasar salad was tough."
• "The pink pancakes had no taste at all. It was very bland."
• "The $20 drink was over priced."
• "None of the four drinks were good, they probably used cheap alcohol."
• "The food was not worth the price and needed salt."