Hunt & Fish Club Reviews Summary

Category: Steak house New York

Address: 125 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

Phone: +13476251220

Rating: 4.3
based on 211 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The gentlemen in the restroom did make my day, never experienced a that friendly guy that turns the water on/off for you and presses on the soap dispenser for you."
  • "Service was excellent and very attentive."
  • "Service was perfect."
  • "Great meal and service from Rosa."
  • "The staff was amazing."
  • "We received top tier service from Carlos, who very hospitable and professional."
  • "The staff very attentive including the general manager who came up to our table to make sure we were enjoying our meal."

Cons:

  • "The service and staff were not very nice."
  • "The service was extremely slow."
  • "He did not ask us for our IDs, he did not ask us if we were ordering drinks, nothing."
  • "Our server, Jorge, was very rude and passive aggressive."
  • "Our server was nice but basically non-existent."
  • "Service is adequate, took way to long get our check."
  • "The service was also disappointing, the food took too long to arrived and the waiter seems like he didn't have much experience."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The restaurant was gorgeous."
  • "Starting off is the decor: beautiful, classy, VERY New York."
  • "From the moment you walk in, the ambiance is fantastic."
  • "The ambiance, music, and experience was magnificent."
  • "Gorgeous decor and vibe."
  • "The ambiance was beautiful."
  • "The ambiance is romantic, dark yet candle lit."

Cons:

  • "Even though my husband made reservations we were sat downstairs in the basement. When I walk down there I could smell a hint of mold, just a basement smell."
  • "I did not like the over the top dim lights."
  • "The restrooms were out of order so an entire restaurant had to share 1 stall near the coat check."
  • "Although we had reservations and the room restaurant had plenty of available seating we were conveniently put right next to the waiters station."
  • "The lighting though is quite dark."
  • "The ambiance is dark so obviously the flash would stand out."
  • "Seating is too tight, especially small tables for 2 with dividers."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "It was an amazing meal and worth every penny."
  • "I had a 6 oz filet mignon and it was delicious."
  • "The 24-ounce bone in ribeye was well seasoned, and cooked perfectly."
  • "The food was delicious, the staff very attentive."
  • "The food was extremely tasty."
  • "The food was seasoned to perfection."
  • "The food is literally not even 5 stars more like 100 stars. The food was very tasty and flavorful."

Cons:

  • "The only let down was the 24 layer chocolate cake. It is a huge slice, but somewhat dry and not very flavorful."
  • "The crab taste like it was low quality and came from a can and the French onion soup which I specifically chose because it had short rib in it was GROSS it literally taste like a bowl of pot roast gravy."
  • "The brussel sprouts had way too much vinegar on them, the lobster was boiled and bland and the mash potatoes were like soup."
  • "The food was absolutely horrible. The steaks crust was showered in salt and was terribly cooked."
  • "The lobster Mac and cheese left a lot to be desired... maybe the lobster. It's like a teaspoon of minced lobster."
  • "The lobster was over cooked and all the dishes were tasteless."
  • "The steak was really dry and bland, the sauce accompanied with it did not taste good."

Value

Pros:

  • "We were here for restaurant week where we got a prix fixe dinner for $60. Quite a good deal!"
  • "Food, of course, is expensive but totally worth it."
  • "The food is quite high pricy, but definitely worth it."
  • "We paid 450 for two which was fine with us both because we had an amazing dinner."
  • "Food was tasty and reasonably priced!"
  • "The menu is a bit pricey, but we caught it during restaurant week where I got clams and small steak for 26 bucks."
  • "Sooo much food being served, so I’d say you get what you’ve paid for and then some."

Cons:

  • "VERY EXPENSIVE OUR BILL WAS $700."
  • "Everything was so, so BLAND."
  • "Food is deff not worth the price."
  • "Food is fine, nothing special, totally overpriced."
  • "Very Over priced & over hyped. Drinks were $20 minimum! Overpriced."
  • "For the price, not worth it."
  • "Also the prices were too high with a side of vegetables costing $16."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.