Tudor City Steakhouse Reviews Summary

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "The atmosphere was warm and cozy with a great view of the river."
• "It's a beautiful space, roomy and warm, classic New York and fresh, at the same time."
• "Really pleasant atmosphere with live music and excellent staff."
• "What a wonderful restaurant with great atmosphere."
• "All around great, cozy atmosphere."
• "The environment was wonderful."
• "We love the ambiance and the live piano music."

Cons:

• "Something has gone terribly wrong with the decor and mood of this new place."
• "The decor is a mishmash of old and new and is not appealing."
• "Lights need to be brought down. The excessive amount of plants removed."
• "The decor is bland and uninviting and, terribly over-lighted."
• "Sadly this place still lacks a lot of taste & presentation."
• "Tune that piano or lose it; it ruins meals and the entire experience."
• "We walked into what appears to be a nice restaurant and experienced a foul smell that existed until we got to our table."

Service

Pros:

• "The service was impeccable. Our waiter was top notch."
• "Daniella had great customer service."
• "George, my server, was so attentive and I had a great conversation with him and his service could not have been better."
• "Delightful! Wonderful service- the waiters were elegant and made us feel like family."
• "We were really attended to by our server George who made sure that everything we ordered was prepared to perfection."
• "The service was outstanding."
• "Staff really goes above and beyond in service."

Cons:

• "The staff and service was terrible."
• "The service was slow and somewhat clumsy."
• "Super nice staff but very slow service."
• "The service was very slow even though the restaurant was pretty empty when we ordered."
• "Terrible service. On Valentine’s Day....waited 13 minutes for a menu."
• "Food is decent, service atrocious! Some of the worst service I have had recently."
• "The service wasn't good. The waiters were frustrated and unorganized."

Food

Pros:

• "By far the best rib-eye I have ever eaten!"
• "Food was hot and very tasty. Desert was out of this world."
• "The food was absolutely delicious."
• "A fine brook trout, steak was lovely, salmon and really all the terrific food and service couldn’t be better."
• "The steak was juicy well seasoned with perfect cuts."
• "The food is also really nice, the porterhouse for 2 is amazing."
• "Everything was delicious! The NY Strip steak was seasoned and cooked perfectly."

Cons:

• "The worst restaurant I've ever visited in New York."
• "Over price for what it is."
• "The spinach was served without cream. My pasta special was a mess."
• "Mine was one of the worst burgers I ever had."
• "The vegetarian lasagna was bad. Carrots & eggplant only & the steak was flavorless."
• "Food was terrible, and service was awful. It took them 2 hours to bring my food out, and the steak was very overcooked."
• "They got both our orders wrong, didn’t complain cause again the service was horrible."

Value

Pros:

• "For all this amazing food drinks dessert and topnotch service at only $400 this place cant be beat."
• "Happy Hour all day long at the bar, $8 for wins and old fashioned, $8 for bar bites."
• "We got the Pri Fix dinner, best value."
• "The surrounding park and city views are also a big plus if you are looking to wander/relax nearby in the vicinity or take pictures."
• "Food was yummy and very reasonably priced for Manhattan steakhouse."
• "Happy hour has great drinks and bar bites to choose from."
• "The steak fries had a nice crisp outside and a soft pillowy inside."

Cons:

• "There really is no reason to go here unless you live in Tudor city and it's raining and you are too lazy to take a cab."
• "Spend your $200+ elsewhere."
• "This restaurant is breaking the law by charging a 4% credit card fee at the end."
• "The value for money is not correct at all."
• "I found the portions for the prefixed lunch to be on the small side."
• "Only thing that holds me back from 5 stars is that each side is ala carte as opposed to being included with your meat."
• "Outrages commercial crab cake, and slide of tomatoes with cheese, over price place for the quality and portions."