Brothers BBQ Reviews Summary

Category: Barbecue restaurant

Address: 2402 NY-32, Cornwall, NY 12518, USA

Phone: +18455344227

Rating: 4.5
based on 254 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The meats are always juicy."
  • "The bark was awesome and crispy."
  • "Delicious bbq, big portions, and prices that won't break the piggy bank."
  • "Delicious NC style BBQ."
  • "The brisket was tender and juicy, not to mention the BBQ sauce oh my, excellent."
  • "Best BBQ in the Hudson Valley! Their brisket and pulled pork melts in your mouth."
  • "Every bite was delicious and the bread pudding is an absolute must!! Practically Everything down to the caramel on the desserts is homemade."

Cons:

  • "The pulled pork was a bit dry and not tasty."
  • "Every single one of my family members food wasn't good including the birthday boys."
  • "Honestly I wasn’t impressed, I cook better than this."
  • "Ribs could have been meatier and were dried out."
  • "Very not smokey and very overpriced."
  • "The brisket is probably the best meat here. It is exceptional!"
  • "The fried chicken sandwich was way overcooked and so the chicken didn't taste great and was tough to chew."

Service

Pros:

  • "Had the best experience with our waitress Amanda. She was quick and attentive and just overall a very nice person."
  • "The waitress Amanda was very sweet and so cool. She definitely knows her information."
  • "Great and fast service."
  • "Great service in a friendly atmosphere."
  • "Service was quick and friendly."
  • "The staff is always on point and accommodating to all our needs."
  • "The wait staff is warm and friendly, and always seem to remember our drink orders (and usually our dinner orders)."

Cons:

  • "Table and condiments were sticky."
  • "Service is okay but a bit slower (they were short staffed)."
  • "Horrible customer service... tried placing an order for over 30 mins for takeout and kept placing me on hold immediately after the phone rang and would proceed to hang up the call 1 min later."
  • "The service is not good at all. You wait too long for your take out order."
  • "30 minutes in, nothing, 40 minutes in nothing so we asked a couple staff that were running food to other cars on the status of our order, never got a follow up."
  • "Waitress never brought us our drinks for at least 20 minutes until we asked where they were."
  • "We were seated immediately, and had our orders taken rather promptly, but after our orders were taken and delivered to the table not once did the server come back to the table."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere is nice."
  • "Great atmosphere. Blues playing loud enough to enjoy but still possible for a table of 4 to carry on a conversation."
  • "The atmosphere was really welcoming."
  • "I was beyond impressed with how clean and family oriented the atmosphere was."
  • "Atmosphere is calming with jazz in the background and tables and decor are like a smokehouse / steakhouse."
  • "It's such a good atmosphere and has entertainment that just gives you a night out of pure enjoyment."
  • "Atmosphere was gr8! The meat was absolutely incredible. Music was a vibe!"

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.