"The brisket is so moist and flavorful. No sauce needed... well, maybe just to try a new flavor profile."
"The brisket was sooo soft it just melts in your mouth like butter."
"Food was well smoked and seasoned."
"Their broccoli salad comes with dried cherries, sliced almonds and bacon, which was very good."
"Dirty frites(fries) are amazing! Brisket burnt ends over fries with bbq sauce and some hot sauce that makes mouth water and nose run with deliciousness!"
"The beef brisket sandwich was tender and flavorful."
"The brisket you get served at Mighty Quinn's is cut in front of you. It's juicy, tender and melts in your mouth."
Cons:
"This location is on 39th and Broadway. Conveniently located off the RQNFM lines. And right next door to Lukes Lobster. So I've been here for a total of three times. Each time I am disappointed in not the service but the food quality."
"The food is ok and the employees are friendly but I was really disappointed in the burnt ends."
"Honestly the food is expensive, my brisket was cold, and it wasn’t ready on time."
"However, their brisket, or pork has been a hit or miss. Sometimes their meat is missing flavor or seasoning."
"Food---brisket was fatty and 1/3rd was inedible. The turkey was like processed sliced turkey."
"Burnt ends were very dry and I ended up tossing them."
"The brisket looked deceivingly juicy when being cut only for me to bite into in and find it extremly dry and tough."
Service
Pros:
"The staff was sweet and friendly too."
"Yo this place is bomb, you'll meet cool people, good vibe, and the best part is the food."
"Nate was very pleasant and has extraordinary customer service pleasantries."
"Our take out order had a missing item and one wrong dish. Jarren, the manager, was fantastic in not only correcting it but also adding a couple of items to make up for the inconvenience."
"The friendly (and downright flirty) staff gave us a warm welcome."
"The staff were great service with a smile very clean and let you try sides before you order them."
"I had the most outstanding customer service from Sonia and Rhea."
Cons:
"I placed an order for delivery and it never arrived."
"I waited 1 hour for my food after they told me it’ll be ready in 8 minutes."
"I don’t appreciate how managers act immature and don’t know how to be professional in a work place whether guests are there or not."
"Each time I am disappointed in not the service but the food quality. The taste is always dry and sometimes burnt."
"There is no customer service and the whole team seems to have attitude, feel kind of tense when walking in the store."
"The oy problem I had is that the staff seem to be super confused while taking orders."
"Some members of the staff seemed bothered and irritated."
Value
Pros:
"The prices and food was lovely, why buy food from McDonalds when for the same sort of money you can enjoy a good atmosphere and better food."
"Portion sizes are generous and prices are reasonable for what you get."
"The portions for the price were AMAZING! I was so full from the brisket & brussel sprouts."
"Very good, juicy brisket. Large servings (the sandwich really filled me up). Fantastic service; the lady who helped me out was super kind and gave fantastic recommendations."
"The 2 meat platter comes with slaw and is all the smoked meat you can eat for under $20."
"A solid spot for lunch thanks to a very affordable meal despite being in an area known for tourism."
"Ordered multiple sides to share - portion sizes are generous."
Cons:
"Food is consistently good - the brisket and sweet corn fritters are delicious - but I think it is a bit overpriced even for NYC."
"For two lunches the tab came to $32 so don't expect to leave here without spending more than one normally would on fast food lunch in midtown."
"The only downside was that there was a ton of liquid on the bottom and it was kind of expensive for the size."
"Honestly the food is expensive."
"This place is a bit on the pricey side."
"Good barbecue, but the way it’s served detracts from its quality... the price is what you’d expect if you were at a sit-down restaurant."
"The seating, service and cutlery is just like any typical fast food restaurants but price is not that cheap."
Ambiance & Location
Pros:
"This particular location it's nicely designed."
"Small place, almost walked by. BBQ is excellent! Self service, order via an iPad type device."
"Service was great and the location is conviently set right between 34th hearald Square and times Square 42nd street great for tourist visiting this area of the city."
"I enjoy the old fashioned wooden table, and dark look of the place, with the smell of barbeque in the air."
"Atmosphere was A1 I couldn’t ask for a better dining experience."
"Visited Mighty Quinn's Barbeque Midtown New York city, we had the brisket which was by far the best we have ever tasted."
"THE STAFF here of 3 women at the front were very professional, caring, knowledgeable and took pride in their jobs."
Cons:
"This location is smaller than some other locations, so getting the full restaurant experience will not happen here."
"Misleading to say the least. Website pictures made the food looked high end, when in fact it was served on what only can be described as a prison tray."
"The seating was pretty tight. There were only about 20 seats available."
"You can find better BBQ anywhere else. Trust that the food is okay but for the lack of seats, long lines and small portions you will do better elsewhere."
"It's more of a fast food type place than a restaurant in terms of the seating options."
"The place also looked like it needs a good clean."
"Music too loud to talk to friends on the other side of the table."