Mighty Quinn's Barbeque Reviews Summary

Meat Quality

Pros:

• "The brisket had a great taste, was tender and very flavorful."
• "The bbq is pretty tasty. Brisket was slightly dry but the bbq sauce (delicious and vinegary) helped so it’s not that big of a deal."
• "Amazing brontosaurus rib! Love the burnt ends."
• "The brisket was so tender and flavorful that I only needed to use my fork to pull a bite off the piece."
• "The ribs were great best thing."
• "The brisket is full of flavor and lean with a good bark."
• "The meats are cooked to perfection, boasting a beautiful smoke ring and a mouthwatering crust."

Cons:

• "Burnt Ends taste like beef jerky.. Not tinder at all(not even close to other smokehouses tried elsewhere)."
• "The ribs were not great as they were a little too dry and not enough meat on them."
• "The meat itself was just ok."
• "The burnt ends were very fatty, drowning in a mediocre sauce."
• "Meat was fatty & bland. Chicken was dry."
• "The brisket isn’t all that moist, the shredded meats are dry."
• "For as good as the brisket and ribs can be, the inverse is true for the burnt ends and pulled pork, both of which border on disgusting."

Service

Pros:

• "The staff was friendly and helpful. The decor was nice."
• "The staff is super friendly and helpful."
• "Service is always good, and have never had a bad experience here."
• "Service was efficient and friendly."
• "Staff is always super friendly and welcoming."
• "Great service, very friendly staff."
• "Service is definitely 5 stars. There were only 2 employees that we could see there and both were phenomenal."

Cons:

• "Awful service from the person taking the orders."
• "I can tell they didn’t enjoy their jobs."
• "The front staff of four women were uninviting, not friendly with a 'whatever' attitude."
• "The most joyless bunch of misery guts staff I experienced all week in NYC."
• "Service is incredibly slow. Pickup times are 20+ minutes late."
• "This was genuinely one of the worst restaurant customer service experiences I’ve ever had."
• "The employees there were very unfriendly."

Price and Portion Size

Pros:

• "Their prices aren't bad."
• "Excellent value for money."
• "Very affordable and all options are delicious and come in generous portions."
• "Best part? The price. Great value."
• "You get a lot for your money, make no mistake about that."
• "Some of the best and cheapest BBQ I've had the pleasure of eating in NYC."
• "Good portions and reasonable prices."

Cons:

• "The price was high and the portions were underwhelming to say the least....I'm talking 3-4 bite portions of meat for $15+."
• "But I think very overpriced."
• "Portions of Brisket or Burnt Ends are tooooo small."
• "The meal of brisket with a side is weighed and very expensive."
• "The lack of a two meat combo or a sampler platter because it costs too much to order everything a la carte."
• "I wouldn’t spend $15+ for a meal here."
• "The prices are a little steep for the portion sizes."

Sides and Extras

Pros:

• "I really liked the burnt ends as well as the mac and cheese."
• "The broccoli salad is also delicious."
• "The sweet potato casserole side and the bread and butter pudding dessert are both must tries."
• "The Mac and cheese was one of the most flavorful I have ever had."
• "The sweet potato casserole is to die for, contains delicious pecans."
• "The corn fritter we're pretty good as well. They were dense, every item had corn in them, and paired perfect with a dab of the honey chipotle sauce."
• "The sides they have provide a nice balance to that flavor, like the coleslaw. I recommend it since it also comes with a sandwich!"

Cons:

• "The corn bread is as cold as your ex girlfriend. And the mouthfeel is like cake."
• "The beans were a bit too sweet for my taste."
• "Sides shouldn’t be the stars at a barbecue joint, but the sides did outshine the meat here."
• "Salad selection was ordinary(no collared greens) and taste boring."
• "The portion size of the slaw was really small."
• "The Mac and cheese was pretty average, which bummed me out."
• "The sides have always been dreadful and overpriced."