Pik Nik BBQ Reviews Summary

Category: Barbecue restaurant

Address: 45 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

Phone: +19146315600

Rating: 4.4
based on 201 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The ribs were so flavorful and would fall right off the bone."
  • "The food prepared here wakes up your taste bud in a delectable way."
  • "The sweet potato wedges are baked and delicious, ditto for the mac and cheese!"
  • "The brisket and ribs had a dry under and over cooked taste."
  • "The burnt ends and prime beef brisket were cooked to perfection, with that mouth-watering smoky flavor we crave."
  • "The meats were amazing, from the flavor, to how tender and juicy they were."
  • "The ribs and pulled pork portions were generous and tasty without the sauce."

Cons:

  • "The brisket taco was pretty poor. Brisket & sauce were ok. The taco shell (flour, not corn) was slightly overdone around edges."
  • "The daily special Carolina pulled pork was burnt and cold."
  • "The Ribs had a lot of fat and weren’t that flavorful."
  • "The sweet potatoes wedges were not cooked all the way."
  • "The cornbread was dry with no taste."
  • "The brisket literally could not stay on the fork."
  • "The food is inconsistently prepared. Sometimes seasoned, sometimes not at all."

Service

Pros:

  • "Whatever Carl recommends will be a great delight!!!"
  • "The hospitality here is not only impressive but impeccable just like their sauce."
  • "Staff is always very friendly, and food is always consistent."
  • "The service was also excellent."
  • "The staff is great! Friendly and courteous."
  • "The service was top notch, the two men I dealt with were polite and friendly."
  • "Best service I’ve experienced in a long time!"

Cons:

  • "Dinning in is very tight I do not recommend it! People are massed around you waiting to order or pick up since register is right in front next to tables."
  • "Took a long time for food to come."
  • "We walked in and were not greeted by anyone."
  • "Wait service is negligible and poor."
  • "Service was very slow."
  • "I asked for water multiple times, too a third time to get."
  • "Service was not acceptable, not even close."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The atmosphere - incredible, I loved it!"
  • "They played a mixture of incredible music, the guests were enjoying themselves, overall a very vibrant, laid back atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere was not only appealing and comfortable but the food was excellent."
  • "Cool corner restaurant with southern charm."
  • "PikNik is beautiful all around, the design, the setting, right in the heart of the village, and it feels like that, with the loveliest staff and ownership and feel."
  • "Nice, casual atmosphere, awesome music and AMAZING FOOD!!!"
  • "The decor is very southern and the place has that smokey smell of delicious bbq."

Cons:

  • "The bread pudding was too wet for me."
  • "Very disappointed in the $61.00 that we were charged for."
  • "The cornbread was a great side choice. Small space but they move people through quickly staff friendly."
  • "The tables were very cramped and the table next to us had to ask me to get up so they could get out and i was eating, i hated the experience and felt ripped off."
  • "The place is small and had a take-out/fast food feel to it."
  • "Took my a friend there for dinner last night and initially, I was reluctant to enter because I was expecting a larger restaurant. It's a reminds of a small 50s vibe but with an explosion of color."
  • "The restaurant is small, very small, so we were happy to get a seat."

Value

Pros:

  • "Expect to spend $25-30 per person for a full meal and drink."
  • "You get a lot of food for you money."
  • "The food was great. Came upon this on a whim walking down Main Street while visiting from New York City."
  • "Amazing food and great prices."
  • "For $35 got us more than 2 people could eat."
  • "My pulled-pork sandwich contained a generous portion of meat for the price."
  • "This is our goto place for some of the best BBQ in the area."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.