Round Up Reviews Summary

Category: Barbecue restaurant

Address: 2741 US-9, Cold Spring, NY 10516, USA

Phone: +18458095557

Rating: 4.5
based on 158 reviews.

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "It has a warm and inviting rustic decor that immediately transports you to a cozy, country-style setting."
  • "Inside is a warm welcoming atmosphere with a nose punch of incredible Smokey flavors."
  • "Music is awesome, food is great and atmosphere is amazing."
  • "Feels like a little getaway to Texas with the ambience."
  • "Seriously good food and comfy atmosphere."
  • "Great place for hikers and bicyclists. This is an out of the ordinary place, for the curious and adventuresome."
  • "The service was great, plenty of parking, live music outside."

Cons:

  • "The place looks run down."
  • "The place itself looks like it's falling apart and the cleanliness is questionable."
  • "The worst is how filthy this place is."
  • "The tables were dirty with food/spills and the garbage inside were you discard your leftovers was overflowing."
  • "tables and seats are sticky. had to sit on a napkin and bathroom was outside in a shed."
  • "The place may not be the greatest to look at but HOLY COW! Literally."
  • "The place isn’t good looking but I had ribs, brisket, and sausage."

Service

Pros:

  • "Best BBQ we have ever had and always great service!"
  • "Service was alright. Counter service where you order, pay, and they call out your name when your tray of food is ready."
  • "Besides that, services was great and fast."
  • "The cooks and the guy taking orders are fun and exceedingly energetic and efficient."
  • "Staff is friendly and service is quick."
  • "Service is great. The food was delicious."
  • "The staff were friendly and so happy."

Cons:

  • "We ended up waiting over 2-1/2 hours for our food (no exaggeration)."
  • "Didn’t have the opportunity to try the food this time because the service on this trip was poor."
  • "They have great BBQ but horrendous service."
  • "Staff is unfriendly. Won’t be going back."
  • "Absolutely ridiculous that they wouldn't inform you when you call."
  • "Everyone who says this place is good has obviously no clue what REAL Texas BBQ is."
  • "Just a very 2 star experiment."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The marbled brisket is my favorite, but I have never been disappointed with anything I've gotten there."
  • "The brisket is great though!"
  • "The brisket and ribs are really well prepared."
  • "Brisket that was tender, ribs, and sausage. Everything is bursting with flavor, well cooked, and authentically made."
  • "The wings, brisket were cooked perfectly."
  • "Ribs so tender they fall off the bone."
  • "The ribs had me speechless. I just could not have enough of the dark, smokey, melt-in-you-mouth, falling off the bone goodness."

Cons:

  • "The brisket was served to us pretty cold/room temperature."
  • "The food was tasteless. We got ribs and briskets, which were dry."
  • "All 3 meats were dried out, and by the color, appeared to be a couple days old."
  • "Paid $27 for a rack of ribs that were mushy, grey, and fell right off the bone."
  • "Beef brisket was a big disappointment. Had high hopes but dry cheap meat for $8 1/4 pound not a repeat."
  • "food was pretty bad, wings were plain and with the added sauce on top were just okay; the ribs were depressing, they look boiled."
  • "Food was super meh. It’s not served properly. It’s almost tasteless."

Value

Pros:

  • "And it's affordable by NY BBQ standards."
  • "Great food, affordable, friendly, fast, inside and outside seating and we can even bring the dog!"
  • "For four guests, $54.00 for lunch sandwiches (2 of which were kiddie size), sides, wings and ice teas. A nice respite."
  • "We spent $50ish total. Not the cheapest food to grab for lunch, but there were 4 of us, and that breaks down to $12ish each. It was a manageable cost."
  • "Food was amazing and very reasonably priced."
  • "Great value for money."
  • "If you have a good appetite, plan on spending $30/person or so."

Cons:

  • "We put most of our food on top of the overflowing garbage and lamented the loss of the $60 bucks we spent in this place!"
  • "Food was ok but beware that prices online aren't correct. Order for pick up. Was planning on $60 when looking online. Got there to pick up and it was $79.21."
  • "I paid almost 40 bucks for a three meat combo with two sides and they have the nerve to add 3% because you use a credit card."
  • "I was expecting a lot more for the $$$."
  • "Dry pulled Chicken at almost $30/pound? This stuff will suck the saliva out of your mouth if you don't drench it in sauce."
  • "The brisket was good but the other things I have gotten were very inconsistent."
  • "You can miss it when driving by, owner should have signs 200 ft. In both directions to give you a chance to stop in."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.