"All food is fresh and dressings, desserts home made."
"The broiled chicken was juicy upon first cutting into it."
"The meat loaf was surprisingly very good."
"Corned beef hash with scrambled eggs on top of the hash with home fries, small OJ, and toast was my order today. It was so tasty I ordered a second plate of hash and eggs. Absolutely delicious."
"I had the fried chicken basket that was just like home cooking but better because I didn't cook it!"
"The corned beef hash is fantastic."
"The food and deserts are fantastic."
Cons:
"The food was horrible, frozen hamburger patties and frozen vegetables.. not even sure they were real meat."
"The Italian dressing was nothing more than red wine vinegar."
"Mightis well have been eating AIR! No seasonings at all! Very disappointing!"
"The meat lasagna was basically meatless and flavorless."
"The beef barley soup was made with ground beef and the veggies were the size of a pencil point, but loads of barley and no flavor."
"The corn was old and didn't taste like corn to be honest."
"The chicken has no flavor what so ever it didn't even had pepper and salt."
"The waitress was hustling. She was quick and attentive to your table of 4."
"The waitress was nice. She promptly took our order and brought our drinks then food."
"Service was FANTASTIC."
"Friendly staff!! She took good care of me!!"
"The service is warm, friendly and inviting."
"The waitress was great and very attentive to us."
Cons:
"Came in for breakfast with my wife, the waitress decided to take the order of the couple that came in after us and was tending to everyone else around us and acted like we didn't even exist."
"Waitress provided poor service...and barely greeted us and never came back to ask if we needed more water."
"The customer service sucked‼️ I asked for scrambled with cheese eggs, pancakes. Never was offered water."
"Walked in and 2 people possibly owner or manager and host just sat there no smile no nothing so had to ask if sitting selves and food was awful it had no flavor or taste and chicken was very dry"
"For over 5 minutes I stood at the entrance waiting to be seated as the waitress walked by 3 times and wouldn't say a word."
"The woman at the door was NOT welcoming at all, it actually felt like we were an inconvenience."
"Our server was not attentive… she dropped our food and took off before we could even ask for mayonnaise, napkins, more water."
Cleanliness & Atmosphere
Pros:
"The tables etc were clean."
"Nice and relaxing family dinner."
"Very clean."
"This is a clean quiet place with good service reasonably priced and banging!"
"Great little old school diner."
"When a diner is really a diner! Not a very fancy place(and doesn't need to be), yet clean with good food!"
"This homey, old time diner has great service and great prices."
Cons:
"The place is dirty, unsanitary, smelly."
"The windows and blinds (right next to the table) were not."
"Food was pretty poor for the price and the whole place has a grungy feel."
"Outdated look is fine. Worn out and outdated is bad."
"The restaurant is in desperate need of a makeover. A bit old and dingy."
"The approach of the diner is grubby. Lots of cigarette buts on the ground and it smells like it."
"Inside the diner is grubby and worn out, smells funky."
Value
Pros:
"Food was inexpensive. My sandwich and fries were ok."
"Overall, a great value."
"I love this place because they have prices as if they're still in the 90s-2000 Era."
"Delicious, home style food...good, fast service....very reasonable prices....TRUCK PARKING FOR WHILE EATING....across street from small PILOT truckstop..."
"18 bucks will get you soup, chicken sandwich w/fries and cheesecake so that's pretty reasonable."
"The prices for meals cannot be beat in the area."
"This place is very reasonably priced and not pretending to be something it isn't."
Cons:
"I paid over $12 bucks for a dinner I was not able to eat."
"Food was pretty poor for the price and the whole place has a grungy feel."
"Very tasty, but the portion size was miniscule."
"Low prices but that's accompanied by small portions."
"NOT real good quality food my burger was not real beef,,the fries were good but my mash n gravy were both watery and soda 2 different ones were flat my beer was just kind of cold"
"The mash potatoes tasted like it just came out of the box."
"Booths need to be updated and the overall appearance hasn't changed much in 30 years."
Parking & Accessibility
Pros:
"They even have spaces in the back for semis to park."
"Big truck parking in back."
"Truck parking is available at the back."
"Truck parking. If you going to park, go inside and eat."
"There is truck parking."
"The lot is dirt and a few potholes but it's better than paying for parking at Pilot, and there's parking for about 10 18 wheelers."
"Located conveniently across from Pilot Newburgh truck stop. I-84 exit New York State route 17K."
Cons:
"Its not all that easy getting in or out."
"Really needs an overhaul."
"Just don't go there."
"The atmosphere, however, was a little outdated."
"Servers are what you would expect: not trained, dressed in whatever street clothes."
"The restaurant is in desperate need of a makeover. A bit old and dingy."
"Booths need to be updated and the overall appearance hasn't changed much in 30 years."