River Star Diner Reviews Summary

Category: Diner

Address: 14 NJ-57, Hackettstown, NJ 07840, USA

Phone: +19089790626

Rating: 4.1
based on 128 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food is always good and the waitresses are usually on top of things."
  • "I am very picky about pancakes, and these were delicious, absolutely perfect."
  • "Their French fries were delicious, in my opinion. Crispy outside, soft inside."
  • "The food was abundant and delish ish!!"
  • "The eggplant parmesan was delicious, had to take half of it home."
  • "They have one of the best burgers I've had anywhere."
  • "Love they have broccoli and spinach sauteed in garlic. Best ever!"

Cons:

  • "The steak, though asked to be well done, was burnt and the mushroom soup was warm not hot."
  • "The food was lukewarm, the omelette left a lot to be desired (bland-even with the type that was ordered) and the egg quesadilla was soggy."
  • "Pancakes unfortunately were flavorless and doughy."
  • "How you going to serve French onion soup with no cheese.. I got a cup of oily onion!!"
  • "Our burgers were sooo well done, when asked for them to be med, and rare."
  • "The Philly Steaks they brought me instead were really bad as well."
  • "Had a blueberry waffle and it looked amazing- till I had some blueberries. Awful definitely frozen."

Service

Pros:

  • "Friendly staff that were attentive."
  • "Service was extremely friendly and food was delicious."
  • "The food was excellent, and the service was top-notch."
  • "The waitress's are very nice an fast... BEST DINER AROUND"
  • "The service was excellent and everyone was kind and polite."
  • "Excellent food, huge portions and the girls are super attentive."
  • "The service was, in a word... Awesome!"

Cons:

  • "The waitress didnt introduce herself."
  • "Turned away an hour before close."
  • "We felt really rushed & they also got my order wrong."
  • "The whole experience was super unprofessional."
  • "The one waitress NEEDED to shut up!!!"
  • "The manager refused to take the cards."
  • "Service SUCKS!!"

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "What a lovely quaint old fashioned diner."
  • "Restaurant was clean and not too crowded when we went for dinner."
  • "This diner was built right on the edge of a small river which is where the name came from."
  • "Classic NJ diner next to a very scenic small river, which provides nice views if you sit in the dining area along the wall that has nice windows overlooking the water."
  • "While it was warm out, the tables with umbrellas kept the sun off of us, and the outside tables were placed right near a small river, which gave us a refreshing cool breeze."
  • "It's family owned and a great place for an inexpensive meal."
  • "It has a nice cozy atmosphere with comfy booths and nice frosted glass accents."

Cons:

  • "The floors to say the least were DIRTY AND DISGUSTING!"
  • "Floors were dirty with crumbled up napkins and food debris."
  • "The booths could use some new cushions! My seat had duct tape all over it!"
  • "Whoever was in charge of cleaning up needs to be fired."

Value

Pros:

  • "The food was delicious and the prices are low."
  • "Definitely a must try now with the outside seating."
  • "Great place, great value."
  • "The food was just as yummy as it was in 2017!"
  • "The food was unbelievable, especially since the prices were so reasonable."
  • "Large serving sizes - I got enough for two meals."
  • "Both dishes were very large portions, and very good."

Cons:

  • "Charged us for items that we were not told were an extra."
  • "However, I was seated way in the back side where nobody was."
  • "We spent a bit over $30 but it was not nearly worth $15."
  • "Expensive! Charged $12 for a Taylor ham, egg and cheese sandwich with fries."
  • "Our trip was a little pricey for just two people, but worth it."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.