St. Mazie Bar & Supper Club Reviews Summary

Category: Live music venue Brooklyn, New York

Address: 345 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

Phone: +17183844808

Rating: 4.5
based on 175 reviews.

Ambience

Pros:

  • "Felt like been in a time machine which took me back to early Twentieth century vibe."
  • "Outdoor seating in the street is great, but it's the live music in the beautiful little garden at the back that really makes this place special."
  • "Everywhere you look is such attention to detail and tells a story of a time long ago."
  • "Quiet, intimate and romantic experience."
  • "The restaurant was very nice and cozy."
  • "Warm ambiance, romantic (mostly-candle) lighting."
  • "The atmosphere was perfect - very dark, cozy, speak-easy vibe."

Cons:

  • "Visually a little too dark."
  • "It was hot and humid and loud making conversation and ordering difficult."
  • "There was live entertainment. But too loud combined with pretty bad accoustics made it difficult to enjoy."
  • "Great ambiance, but service was really bad and the food was just ok."
  • "But too loud combined with pretty bad accoustics made it difficult to enjoy."
  • "Near the end of the dinner we started having twigs from the overhanging plants rain on us."
  • "We were seated out front and it smelled like urine at our table."

Service

Pros:

  • "Awesome service."
  • "I was blown away by the manager coming over and checking in on her to make sure she was comfortable and enjoying herself."
  • "Solid and friendly service across the board from hostess to server."
  • "Our waitress however was super kind, she offered us desserts."
  • "The staff were all incredibly helpful."
  • "Service was attentive, fast, and reliable."
  • "Service was great, and drinks were excellent."

Cons:

  • "Waited over 20 minutes for 2 N/A cocktails."
  • "Our service was kinda slow - we sat down at 7 and didn’t have a waiter come up to us for almost 15 min."
  • "They lost our credit card (gave back just the bill without the card) and then blamed us for losing it…"
  • "Nothing was taken off our bill. The worst. Really disappointed as this place had great reviews."
  • "Found service quite slow."
  • "They take 30 min to serve a beer, mix the total at the end."
  • "Truly the worst service I have ever had."

Food & Drinks

Pros:

  • "The food is very tasty. The cocktails are seriously good too."
  • "Pork shoulder and risotto were insane."
  • "Dinner was utterly amazing,from the curry butter squash soup, arugula salad, to our entrees of seafood stew and a chicken arugula sandwich with a side of potatoes."
  • "Amazing cocktails, and even better jazz band."
  • "The drinks are incredible."
  • "The food was delicious, especially the risotto and burger."
  • "The food was amazing. Brussel sprouts were scrumptious!"

Cons:

  • "Both arrived with several of the gnocchis grainy and undercooked."
  • "However… the food was really disappointing. The padron peppers were a little strange and quite hard, the burger was unfortunately one of the worst I’ve ever tasted."
  • "The food was atrocious and unacceptable."
  • "Every dish seemed to have 3 bulbs of garlic in it which made the food difficult to enjoy."
  • "The food was a bit average."
  • "But the food left a good deal to be desired. Small mussels. Reheated potatoes."
  • "The food was unexpectedly disappointing."

Live Music

Pros:

  • "Great jazzy live music!"
  • "It’s an experience for all of your senses."
  • "They have phenomenal, eclectics live music (usually old fashioned styles)."
  • "The ambience is great, and the live jazz is wonderful."
  • "The jazz was great, albeit a bit cramped."
  • "Live big band & gypsy jazz."
  • "The jazz trio was great as well."

Cons:

  • "The only thing that makes me feel discouraged from visiting is the crowd (they tend to talk over the musicians)."
  • "But I saw a huge rat 🐀 low-key crawling the trellis near the back wall... (It's not their fault but it was horrifying...😭)"
  • "But the live music didn’t line up with their schedule so we ended up only catching the first part of a set."
  • "Music and cellar vibes are cool and everything is reasonably priced."
  • "The entertainment at the bar is usually very entertaining - I’ve seen jazz and flamenco dancing on the small stage here."
  • "This is the perfect place for a jazz night."
  • "Live salsa music started at 1030, Saturday, other nights feature jazz I'm told."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.