Evergreen Dairy Bar Reviews Summary

Category: Ice cream shop

Address: 1643 NJ-70, Southampton Township, NJ 08088, USA

Phone: +16096548585

Rating: 4.7
based on 148 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Our waitress amber was very accommodating to my food allergies, and great personality which I appreciate very much so."
  • "Absolutely delicious food and amazing service!!"
  • "Service is good, and it's inexpensive."
  • "The service is excellent. The staff goes above and beyond."
  • "Our orders came out quickly. We had a GREAT breakfast! Our meals were fresh, hot, generous and delicious!"
  • "The staff was extremely friendly."
  • "Excellent food and even better service."

Cons:

  • "Stopped in for ice cream on a Sunday afternoon. Only 4 persons in front of me. Took 25 minutes to be served."
  • "Young counter girls do not have a sense of urgency; do not appear to have a system for serving customers."
  • "Service was a bit slow but friendly and kind."
  • "Even when not busy (1130 am summer Friday) super long waits for both take out food orders (20 mins)and ice cream window service (20 mins). Won't stop here again, no matter how good the food is."
  • "Staff Didn't Wear Any Masks when serving food!"
  • "They had very few hard flavors and were not very forth coming to help or give info."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The style of this place is like stepping back in time in the best way."
  • "Retro atmosphere is so fun and cozy."
  • "The old school vibes are immaculate-go on Tuesdays and you’re sure to see a ton of classic or customized cars."
  • "Great retro drive-in that has been there since 40's."
  • "Old school restaurant with an old school feeling."
  • "Everybody was in a great mood, great atmosphere and very friendly."
  • "Outside covered picnic tables provide a nice little break from the long hot drive home from the beach."

Cons:

  • "The customer bathroom which is a Port-A-Potty when I opened the door I almost Vomit 🤮 on the spot and quickly closed the door!! 🤮YUCK!"
  • "The bathroom facilities are one person capacity and not handicap ADA compliant."
  • "The atmosphere is loud and busy."
  • "And ambiance is nice if you just ignore the highway traffic."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The soft-serve is one of the best I've ever tasted."
  • "Loved every bite!! The fries were my favorite - super flavorful and non greasy."
  • "I just recently tried their pumpkin ice cream and it was just divine! You get the pumpkin flavor but it’s not too sweet - just right!"
  • "The food was wonderful, the prices were great and the service was wonderful."
  • "Food is always plentiful and good."
  • "The food was delicious and it came out quicker than I expected."
  • "The food was the best and to top it off you could not beat the prices."

Cons:

  • "I was charged $5 for what looked like a sample amount of frozen yogurt that had already had a soupy ring around it where it had quickly begun to melt."
  • "I was shocked how bad it was, the scrambled eggs were beat up fried egg and the pancakes were cold and dry."
  • "The food was also of poor quality bacon tasted 'like fried in old grease and poorly cooked."
  • "Food was totally fine but nothing exceptional."
  • "The ice cream is alright, it's good but I've had better in a few other places."
  • "Disappointing. It's overpriced for what it offers."

Value for Money

Pros:

  • "It's inexpensive."
  • "We loved this quaint mom and pop like diner very clean and friendly staff with reasonable prices."
  • "Prices are very affordable, especially compared to other diners in the area."
  • "The food and staff were both excellent."
  • "A great ice cream oasis on Rte 70 !! Huge property, easy parking and plenty of tables for social distancing."

Cons:

  • "I get a fried egg sandwich with no bacon & no cheese on a roll, for $5.75. I stopped there on 5/13/19 and orders the same thing the price went up to $7.70."
  • "If you dont mind spending $8 for little more than a mcdonalds sundae with 2 toppings."
  • "I will never stop there again, plus the bacon wasn't good."

Additional Features

Pros:

  • "Now famous as a location used in the movie, Knock at the Cabin by M. Night Shyamalan."
  • "We went to a 'Trunk r' Treat' event there and it was fantastic!"
  • "They have different games at all their tables for you to play while enjoying some ice cream such as tic tac toe, checkers and uno."
  • "They have games out on the picnic table (like Connect Four and other family games) to play with friends and family."
  • "Tuesday's are classic car day."
  • "Stop here for car shows, vending fairs, and all sorts of fun."
  • "Parking galore, an ICE CREAM STAND, and antique cars are there all the time to see."

Cons:

  • "Parking could've been advertised better."
  • "Table was a little dirty but we were sitting at a picnic table outside so it's what you would expect."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.