"They have excellent fried calamari- it even reheat well."
"The oysters and clams on half shell were excellent."
"The flounder blt had a thick filet cooked just right and a yummy, slightly spicy sauce."
"Perfectly cooked flounder, shrimp, deviled clam, clam strips and scallops."
"Everything was cooked exactly right and the flavors were Amazing!"
"Food is simply amazing, freshest seafood you can find anywhere in New Jersey."
Cons:
"Broiled seafood was very over done and lobster tail needed a steak knife to cut it."
"Extremely tasteless and had a weird texture."
"The baked potato was as hard as A ROCK."
"They were just a little bit overcooked, still good, but just a little bit overdone."
"The scallops were perfectly done but the breading was way too dark."
"The double portion at $28 with two small sides was disappointing and flavorless."
"The shrimp tasted as if they had been cooked previously and then dumped back in the fryer."
Service
Pros:
"Servers were great and atmosphere was nice."
"Our server who was just on point, she made the night even better."
"The server was absolutely delightful!"
"The one positive was our waitress. She was very pleasant and took care of us."
"The service was excellent."
"Quaint atmosphere & great friendly service!"
"The service is awesome."
Cons:
"When a separate blonde server in her late 30s or early 40s appeared to take our drink orders, her demeanor was quite rushed and irritable."
"Finally a waitress yelled to another waitress about the table while serving another table that came at the same time we did."
"A waitress came and took our orders but it took forever for our selections to arrive."
"At the end our waitress must have forgotten that we were still sitting there so we had to flag her down finally to be able to pay and leave."
"The service was awful. The waitress seemed frazzled."
"It took 20 minutes for the waitress to come and get our drink order."
"Went in at 10 to 2 at 2:30 still no chowder and we ordered 2 bloody Mary's but no one new how to make them they were reading a book on how to make cocktails."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Such a relaxing seafood place! My family had been coming here for over 40 years!"
"It wasn’t crowded when we arrived."
"The atmosphere and interior changes were great."
"Quaint, essential seafood experience off Jersey Shore."
"The restaurant itself is lovely, the atmosphere is nice, clean, friendly."
"It’s very clean in there & decorated really cute."
"This place is so cute. It is an inviting and warm spot for a good meal."
Cons:
"The interior is stark."
"It’s a tiny place and it's very cramped."
"The atmosphere is pretty bland."
"There is definitely a problem when there are more bugs inside than there are outside."
"The food wasn't worth the money at all, the service wasn't great and I was shocked when I did get the check."
"Very slow."
"The shrimp was very over cooked and we couldn't eat without all the flies bombarding us."
Value
Pros:
"The quality of the food for the price is pretty good."
"No frills, just great tasting food at very reasonable prices."
"The prices are reasonable and the food was all very good."
"Stopped for a quick lunch after arriving, they had a lunch soup and sandwich special for only $10!"
"Always fresh and delicious seafood, sometimes you may have to wait for a table but it's definitely worth it."
"The bowl for soup is a meal in itself and a bargain."
"So, my suggestion is to leave the GS Parkway, stop over and enjoy it all for reasonable prices."
Cons:
"We spent $65 on 2 appetizers and 2 platters, could have gone to our local diner and spent way less than that, like $20 less!"
"They shouldn't have the prices so high the food should be FREE."
"Less food, prices through the roof."
"Dinner for two, no appetizers, 2 ice teas and 2 entrees was $75 before tip."
"Prices have Skyrocketed."
"Very disappointed in the serving sizes and portions for the money you spend."
"Drink prices are a little steep but it is what it is lol."