"The initial service was good. Got drinks and food order in quickly."
"Our server was really pleasant."
"The service is attentive and immediate."
"Our waitress Debbie was clearly worked as hard as she could to accommodate our every need."
"Our waitress debby had us in stitches! So funny & so sweet & accommodating."
"Great food, great atmosphere, friendly attentive staff."
"Our server Kristi was very attentive and super friendly."
Cons:
"The manager was not the most professional and really had nothing much to say."
"The service was also very slow."
"They tried to overcharge us for 40 bucks."
"The wait staff and host is incompetent. And management cannot handle themselves when they have a full house."
"The service was also very slow. Took more than 20 mins to bring the food out and the restaurant was less than half full."
"The guy that took our order didn't seem to know what was going on."
"The staff wasn’t friendly at all."
Food Quality
Pros:
"This place rocks!"
"The place was amazing, had an Olde English Cheddar, and it was exquisite."
"I had the fish and chips which was huge and fresh and crispy and nice."
"The food is so delicious, and while a little pricy, so worth it."
"The scallops, shrimp, haddock, and London broil were all cooked well and melted in our mouths."
"The crab cakes were excellent. probably the best thing on the menu."
"Everything was delicious! Loved the French onion soup and salad bar. The crabcakes were absolutely delicious with no fillers, just crab meat."
Cons:
"Parmesan Encrusted Flounder was miserable."
"The oysters were not fresh."
"The snow crab was watery (not cooked enough) and the steak didn't have much flavor."
"The food was below average."
"French fries were not hot, and just 'blah'."
"Scallops were rubbery and barely seared."
"The 'Lobster' spring rolls were odd. It didn't really taste like seafood."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"The atmosphere and service were great!"
"Very homey even though there was a bar."
"The atmosphere was great 👍."
"The atmosphere was pleasant."
"The entire atmosphere was great."
"The atmosphere is really warm and inviting."
"The atmosphere is nostalgic and welcoming."
Cons:
"From what I can tell they've been there a long time and maybe a long time ago it was good but times change."
"The restaurant atmosphere was very dark and dingy."
"The place has a very meandering layout (not sure it's efficient for service). And the deco was dated, tables warn and menus had that sticky look and feel."
"The bathroom was atrocious and my shoes stuck to the floor."
"Upon entrance to the foyer, it smelled of foul, uncleaned odor …."
"The dinning area has rug and that is starting to develop an odor."
"The restaurant itself really needs some up dating. Felt more old and stuffy than warm n cozy."
Value
Pros:
"Get a great meal at a fraction of the price of what you get at the resort."
"The food was delicious & very reasonably priced."
"Also, they have a marketplace where you can buy the seafood in bulk from them, which is so worth it."
"Prices are reasonable and they offer an early bird menu which is great for the wallet!"
"Food prices weren't expensive at all, and you received MORE than expected compared to modern day restaurants😁."
"I was surprised how affordable their prices were."
"The prices were reasonable."
Cons:
"I was extremely disappointed in the full portion size for $29.99."
"Really expensive place for poor standards."
"Extremely overpriced for mediocre food."
"The menu is way overpriced I paid $15 for 4 pieces of shrimp!"
"Food is way to expensive for portion sizes."
"So grossly overpriced for so little actual seafood and mediocre at best."
"Prices have gone way up and the quality is NOT worth it!"