"Good home cooking and some very good craft beers."
"Really good food. The portions here huge too."
"Order buffalo wings (they're the best you'll ever have!) and a beer."
"The food is simply outstanding with impressive portions and superior service."
"The pizza was excellent and our group said the coffee martinis were fantastic."
"The food was super tasty, well cooked and served quickly."
"Food was tasty, but a pricey bill for our meal and drinks."
Cons:
"Wings were not sauced with our order, but a different flavor."
"Great service but AWFUL food."
"The price of one beer at happy hour time was $8, our surprise was that without any reason they charged $9 for each one."
"Should Be Zero Stars. Lunch special is more aptly named RIP- OFF SPECIAL."
"Food was subpar for the price. I had the Rigatoni and noddles were under cooked."
"Drinks are food, food is definitely not the best. Chicken was bland, string beans came from can and mash from a powder box."
"The chicken was over cooked to the point of being jerky."
Service
Pros:
"The service was great and the price was right."
"All staff were very friendly, a special mention to Ro for looking after us, she was the perfect host."
"Very friendly service and the food was good."
"Cathy is awesome and it’s the first pub we’ve been to in NYC that the bar staff took notice."
"The service is surprisingly on point, the wings are good, as the happy hour is possibly one of the best in Manhattan."
"Our waitress was magnificent! She was so accommodating."
"The staff was great, very friendly and attentive."
Cons:
"We got seated down the back in a corner seat that was soaked previous people must of spilt drink all over them."
"The bartender was extremely rude and unprofessional to my pregnant girlfriend."
"Our waiter had a few too many tables so service was a little lacking."
"The blonde haired ponytailed lady gave the impression she didn't want to be there."
"But the really inattentive service for my visit."
"Terrible service. Weak drinks."
"The worst service I've ever had."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"Fish and Chips!! What a sweet spot btwn Penn station and port authority away from all the chaos."
"The atmosphere is electric!"
"Quaint and intimate bar, I really liked the vibe."
"Live music every night and sports on multiple screens."
"Amazing atmosphere, aesthetic, and tap beer."
"The atmosphere, the staff, the food are sensational."
"Interesting and unique atmosphere."
Cons:
"English sports bar (or is that sports pub?) in midtown. Nothing special, basic selection of beers that aren’t cold enough."
"It's another theme park slinging $8 pints."
"You never ever talk down to a customer who just paid for mediocre overpriced food and drink in a place that reeks of bleach."
"Location maybe a bit small and cramped for some though."
"Personally, I didn't need 4 screens with various sports on, all muted though."
"Last thing I expected was to have a three year old running around, broke a glass, and then sat at the bar to eat ice cream."
"Though for an Irish bar with big pretzels and corned beef sandwich on the menu, they only had honey mustard and dijon. No Yellow or brown mustard at all."
Value
Pros:
"This place is great. I treated an out-of-town bud to drinks and dinner here. We both really enjoyed the food (and cocktails)."
"Great. Just walked in because it was just in front of the hotel I stayed. There was a great live singer and met great people hanging around the bar. Hidden gem for drinks."
"The little Irish woman behind the bar is so sweet and fun and offered me a job so honestly this place deserves way more than five stars."
"Found this place wandering around NYC. Best food and drink specials you'll find."
"The beer is also good and the happy hour is 4-7 pm: draught beers, margaritas, cocktail of the day only 6$!"
"Prices are good compared to other spots which charge more for less."
"The happy hour prices were amazing."
Cons:
"Food was tasty, but a pricey bill for our meal and drinks. They automatically charged us 20% tip without consent."
"You basically pay 20% of the cost but nobody serves you 🥲 there’s no possibility to set your own tip percentage."
"Food was subpar for the price. I had the Rigatoni and noddles were under cooked."
"Food was good and atmosphere was good, even service was good. But they gave us a check with 20% gratuity automatically."
"The mushrooms were pretty good, though I'm not sure they were worth $5 a piece."
"They also charge a fee to use a credit card. All in all they charged us $63 in fees."
"A tad overpriced but it's in NYC so I'm not surprised."