The Mean Fiddler Reviews Summary

Category: Irish pub New York

Address: 266 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

Phone: +12123542950

Rating: 4.3
based on 346 reviews.

Atmosphere & Decor

Pros:

  • "The moment I walked in, I feel in love with the decor."
  • "Great environment and service."
  • "Everyone singing and dancing in their seats eating was a whole vibe."
  • "Such a great atmosphere, the people who come here are amazing. Fun and engaging."
  • "The atmosphere is lively and a little loud, but I wouldn't have wanted it any other way."
  • "The atmosphere was amazing."
  • "Amazing ambiance with amazing music and even better service."

Cons:

  • "It was a very noisy and dark place, perfect for watching football with your friends but no celebrating your birthday."
  • "And the atmosphere was dark and sticky. But not in the sexy way."
  • "Place was way too loud for just a quick bite to eat/drink after a show."
  • "The music they played was SO incredibly painfully loud."
  • "Music was so loud you couldn’t hear the person next to you speak."
  • "The music way too loud for a Saturday afternoon lunch."
  • "The atmosphere was mixedβ€”the music was great but way too loud to talk to even talk."

Service

Pros:

  • "Our waitress, Megan, was a joy and even treated us to cinnamon toast crunch shots to celebrate my parents 34th wedding anniversary!"
  • "Mayv was a lovely bartender, so friendly!"
  • "The service was incredibly attentive with the unlimited drinks, highly recommend."
  • "Our Hostess was really good about making sure that our pitchers were always filled."
  • "The bartenders were very friendly."
  • "Very sweet, attentive servers!"
  • "Our server was perfect, the best we had the whole time we were in New York, she was so attentive and friendly."

Cons:

  • "The server almost never checked in on us and I ended up with food poisoning after getting a med well burger."
  • "Our waitress never came back to fill up drinks or even check on us."
  • "Staff was very disorganized and the bottomless drinks were all sugar and no alcohol."
  • "Our server also actively avoided us, serving our neighboring tables and keeping their cups full while we constantly had to flag down other staff members to help us."
  • "Service was horrible, you have to run down your waitress who was just standing around doing nothing but talking to the bar tender."
  • "It seemed like our server was actively avoiding our table."
  • "I DISAGREE WITH 20% GRATUITY BEING AUTOMATIC WHEN WE HAD TO SIGNAL SOMEONE MORE THAN ONCE FOR SERVICE!!"

Food & Drinks

Pros:

  • "They serve the usual pub fare, and if like to highlight their Shepherd Pie, well prepared and flavorful."
  • "This place was awesome!! Food was good and the service was top of the line."
  • "Delicious brunch spot."
  • "The food is good, and the drinks are strong."
  • "Food is delicious, drink menu is great, and the service was fast."
  • "Food was so good, especially the cauliflower bites and the steak quesadilla πŸ˜‹."
  • "The food was great! Everything we ordered was delicious."

Cons:

  • "The food was expensive for the amount that came and the quality was just ok."
  • "I disliked the Fries, only because they were too Krispy for me!"
  • "The bottomless cocktails are not great. Too sweet and weren't pleasant flavors."
  • "Food was decent but not for $60 per person for bar food."
  • "The specialty cocktail was bad. Big, foamy head on the draft Guinness."
  • "The food- nachos- had TOOO MUCH cheese it made me naseuos."
  • "The food was pretty pricy for mediocre food."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.