"The food quality and quantity for the price paid was of incredible value."
"I was very pleased with the BBQ Chicken sandwich on a panini, and the beer was good and reasonably priced."
"Very tasty food, a good beer for an affordable price."
"Great cocktails and tasty food. prices very reasonable."
"Decent prices too for the city."
"Their prices are reasonable for this area considering it is a tourist hub."
"We can thoroughly recommend the Philly Steak roll and the Hawaiian Burger. These specials come with a beer as well for only $18!"
Cons:
"Cocktails advertised @ $14 yet we paid $28 for a vodka/coke and $10 for a pint of Guinness, typically cocktails are more everywhere else."
"Overpriced food for its quality, even for New York."
"Both drinks were very low quality... When it came to the bill they charged us $18 per drink!!!!"
"Beer was ok, but pricey. Quesadilla was poorly made and quite expensive for what you got."
"The steak was terrible not to mention way overpriced."
"We were way overcharged for the food and drinks we purchased."
"You get a half pint for 10 bucks for Guinness no full pints."
Service
Pros:
"Service is great!...just wish they taps were better."
"Great bar with some amazing hospitality."
"Shahi was very helpful with my friend who uses a wheelchair."
"Very kind people they help me a lot just before I went back to the uk."
"The best service I've received in the city!"
"Staff was friendly, lovely, and smiley."
"The staff very friendly, everything very clean."
Cons:
"Service was a little poor... Many others and I, were struggling to get a drink because there was one bartender on one side for a packed bar."
"Service is quick, but not really all that friendly."
"Service must be the upmost importance to the customers... won’t go back."
"Service was terrible. We waited about 35 minutes for someone to take our order for drinks."
"Waited 30 -40 min for our food to come which nobody came back over to refill our drinks."
"Food was OK, service was terrible, waited 15 min for someone to ask what we wanted to drink and get a menu."
"The service was the part that made me never wanna return again if im NYC."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"The Playright 35th, by far, was the most fun-filled stop on our list."
"It's a place with some character and the next time I find myself in NYC, I'd happily return."
"It can be very busy and a little on the noisy side but it is so friendly its great to see the sports fans enjoying themselves."
"Great place for enjoying sports with my friends."
"I loved the vibe in there."
"The whole place is pretty cozy with Christmas decorations and a warm din of chatter."
"The bar has a warm and cozy atmosphere. Just what you're looking for in an Irish pub."
Cons:
"0 ambience, 0 uniqueness."
"Avoid at all costs."
"Steer Clear folks there are many nicer places with a friendlier atmosphere."
"Worst of all, my $10 (!!!) Guinness was not even a pint - per ounce, it may be the most expensive Guinness in NYC."
"I'm not sure about the decor inside, it's always really dark like they're trying to hide dirty secrets - and the view from outside isn't too inviting either."
"The worst part of the experience was the mouse that I saw run across the floor."
"Watch your back in there. Weird things going on."
Food & Drinks
Pros:
"The food is good, and warrants 4 stars from me.. but unfortunately, the tap beers are always blah/sour, and knock it down one star."
"Everything was spot on. Nothing tasted frozen and cheap."
"Craft beer was an excellent Octoberfest and the Martinis ordered by the rest of my party were enjoyed all around."
"The food was delicious, stuff very friendly and helpful."
"Flavorful food - an excellent burger, GOOD fries, LARGE portions."
"The food was delicious, and the place was nice."
"The shepards pie was phenomenal. Easily the best I had near times square!"
Cons:
"Got the Nachos and was SEVERELY disappointed. It was nothing but cheap, bagged tortilla chips, maybe a quarter can of black beans, a scoop of guacamole, and the worst cheese whiz I've ever had."
"My salad was missing ingredients, which the waitstaff eventually corrected."
"It all looks nice & warm until they served 2 of our 4 meals dry (hamburger & salmon just unfrozen)."
"Their chicken pot pie....no frills cream of chicken soup with 3 chunks of chicken and some peas."
"The mushroom burger had zero flavor and the mushrooms came from a can."