The Irish American Pub Reviews Summary

Category: Irish pub New York

Address: 17 John St, New York, NY 10038, USA

Phone: +16464146223

Rating: 4.4
based on 218 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The beef pattie on the burger was huge and well cooked though."
  • "The prime rib was delicious and satisfying."
  • "The food was so tasty!"
  • "The wings were freaking amazing! Some of the best I've had in a while."
  • "Food is delicious and bangers'n'mash are is my absolute favorite at this place."
  • "Their food is decent, it’s like an extension of bar food."
  • "The chicken wings and lamb lollipops are a culinary delight not to be missed."

Cons:

  • "The wine was terrible and overpriced."
  • "Some chips were a little burnt."
  • "Really expensive items, even during happy hour the drinks are about $7."
  • "Food prices trended towards the upper limits of what is acceptable in an inflated economy."
  • "Servers dont understand their menu, food obviously made then frozen."
  • "Entree was returned immediately. Inedible fish and chips."
  • "The fish fillet was quite soggy and dry. Would be nice if it's crispy on the outside and soft juicy on the inside."

Service

Pros:

  • "The service was great."
  • "Service was wonderful, good food."
  • "The entire staff were so friendly and attentive-drinks and food were flowing and delicious."
  • "The staff and management were friendly, helpful, and very responsive throughout the booking process."
  • "The service was great considering how busy they were."
  • "Service: Very attentive and courteous!"
  • "The service here is top tier and all of the employees are extremely personable."

Cons:

  • "The waitress whose name was Nancy led us to the table, gave menu and brought us food but no forkes and knives."
  • "Sadly, the service is very slow."
  • "The wait time for getting a drink was ridiculously long. It appears that the place was understaffed."
  • "Drive to this location hoping to get a beer. The bar was very busy and pact with business people. The bartender made eye contact but did not return to serve me after 13 minutes."
  • "Never saw a waitress. Every table around us were frustrated as well."
  • "After a manager noticed us, she approached and took our order for drinks and food over 20 mins after being seated."
  • "Horrible service. Our server seemed to not be interested in us."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Nice mixed vibe."
  • "Great vibe very busy the night we were there."
  • "The atmosphere was so lively!"
  • "The atmosphere in here was great..just what i imagined a downtown Manhattan bar to be like!"
  • "It was very well lit atmosphere!"
  • "The setting is perfect, great relaxed atmosphere."
  • "This is a hidden gem in Downtown Manhattan."

Cons:

  • "The entrance is a little off-putting as it small and dark."
  • "This place is disgusting. The bathrooms are so nasty with trash old beers and flies everywhere..."
  • "The only thing was that there was a sewer smell Friday night."
  • "The place is disgusting. Bathroom are very dirty with trash and flies everywhere."
  • "Playing the news on every TV, cockroaches scurrying on the floor."
  • "First noticed the dining room was foul smelling."
  • "I didn't want to touch anything in this place."

Price

Pros:

  • "Drinks are well priced too."
  • "Prices are pretty moderate considering that it's located in downtown Manhattan."
  • "Drinks are very reasonably price."
  • "It was a great place with reasonable prices."
  • "Very reasonable prices and good drinks (not watered down)."
  • "The drinks are nicely priced."
  • "The food is great the staff is awesome, the drinks are nicely priced."

Cons:

  • "Really expensive items, even during happy hour the drinks are about $7."
  • "Food prices trended towards the upper limits of what is acceptable in an inflated economy."
  • "They had a few top shelf liquors available for $20 a shot."
  • "Paid 22 bucks for the worst cut/size of fish I’ve ever seen."
  • "Spent about $40/per person with a drink or two each, an appetizer split and tip."
  • "Be wary of a spiked drink."
  • "I never got a call from them, nor did I get my money back. I am very disappointed with this place and I will never be going back."

Entertainment and Activities

Pros:

  • "The only reason to come here is the music."
  • "Drinks are strong and tasty, the space is big, and there's a coin operated pool table."
  • "And they have a live DJ on Saturday and Wednesday- Friday is Karaoke nights with the amazing Shadeya."
  • "Food is great and they have a pool table, ping pong, Foose ball and arcade games! Oh! and Kareoke!"
  • "They have a pool table, ping pong, Foose ball and arcade games! Oh! and Kareoke!"
  • "This is a fun place to relax, burn off some steam playing games like pool, darts, or table tennis."
  • "Love the entertainment, lot of screens inside covering all the area, there is a play zone which got snooker, ping pong and some other games."

Cons:

  • "No cons mentioned regarding entertainment and activities."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.