AmaroneScarlatto Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food was delicious and the service was incredible!!"
• "Incredible Italian food experience with very reasonable pricing."
• "The food was excellent, our waiter was so helpful, witty and attentive."
• "Food was delicious and flavorful."
• "Some of the best authentic, Italian that Hell's Kitchen has to offer."
• "The crispy calamari was amazing probably one of the best I’ve had."
• "The food was outstanding and cooked to perfection."

Cons:

• "I would not advise you to eat seafood here."
• "Desserts, did not meet my expectations, I recommend desserts far from here."
• "However, the filet mignon I ordered was rare, the outside was too burnt and bitter."
• "One of our fish was not eatable at all, we ordered lasagne which was delicious and chicken parmigiana and with this one they have definitely failed."
• "Overcooked, bland pasta was what I had."
• "Everything was covered in the same overpowering lemony sauce."
• "The dishes were bland, but the Orecchiette dish with salmon was the worst."

Service

Pros:

• "Servers are very attentive and knowledgeable about food and drinks selection."
• "The servers are great, everyone had a delightful dinner."
• "Staff was excellent and the owner was walking around to make sure everything was running smoothly."
• "The service was friendly, knowledgeable and can only be described as impeccable!"
• "Service was friendly and very efficient."
• "The staff was wonderful, the food was terrific and the atmosphere was very nice."
• "The staff was attentive and kind. A warm ambience."

Cons:

• "Very bad experience, we’ll never be back."
• "The waiter was very rude! Were served wrong orders, and cold food!"
• "Service: they are accommodating but it is below par."
• "We sat next to the door and we were very cold and had to sit inside with the jacket."
• "We were seated promptly and given water and menus and left to sit and wait for 20 minutes."
• "Service was so slow we almost missed our Broadway shows!"
• "The service at this place was absolutely terrible."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "They had a great spotify playlist which fit the flair."
• "Very cozy during the winter time."
• "The place is bright and comfortable."
• "Great location, nice ambiance and interesting menu."
• "This place is great! Nice atmosphere, staff was very friendly and accommodating."
• "From the moment you step through the doors, the warm and romantic ambiance envelops you, setting the stage for an evening of amore."
• "It is charming and really lovely. Very warm and inviting on the inside."

Cons:

• "Also, there was very little light and there was practically no one dining."
• "Little light and few people inside."
• "The waiter is mean, the lights were low you don’t see the other persons."
• "It got VERY noisy...once tables got filled."
• "But very disappointing was the manager's interrupt and make a comments to us for being loud."
• "The atmosphere is great. The place looks nice and cozy."
• "The restaurant is very cozy and densely packed. The ambiance was excellent."