Taiyaki NYC Japanese Ice Cream Reviews Summary

Category: Ice cream shop New York

Address: 119 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013, USA

Phone: +12129662882

Rating: 4.5
based on 426 reviews.

Ice Cream Quality

Pros:

  • "Ice-cream (Matcha and Hojicha) had the perfect consistency."
  • "The soft serve was amazing, amazing presentation combined with superb flavor."
  • "Their ice cream flavors are delicious and there are many choices."
  • "Very delicious, the warm 'taiyaki cone' and the cold ice cream go so well together."
  • "Absolutely amazing ice cream and served in a super cute fashion."
  • "The ice cream is good!"
  • "The soft serve is very good, the sesame flavor is particularly strong and flavorful, very nutty and good."

Cons:

  • "We ordered Matcha/Hojicha ice cream but taste nothing..."
  • "The fish ice creams look really beautiful BUT the matcha ice cream tasted like cod liver oil."
  • "The ice cream was really mid. Not sure why it has such high rating. Would not recommend."
  • "The matcha ice cream, not so much. Maybe add some vanilla to balance the flavor because it was almost powdery and bitter."
  • "Icecream was okayish. Little too sweet for me but cant complain much."
  • "I got pumpkin flavor I believe, I didn’t really like it and cone tasted like apple spice (gross taste)."
  • "This ice cream was pretty good but way overpriced for what you get."

Customer Service

Pros:

  • "Super friendly staff that knew their product and were very helpful and insightful on popular items from their menu."
  • "Staff was very friendly!"
  • "Customer service was great."
  • "The staff were very friendly and patiently tolerated all our requests to sample different flavors."
  • "Very friendly upon walking in and super helpful with any questions we had."
  • "Staff are courteous and efficient."
  • "The staff is extremely polite and very friendly and the store is super clean."

Cons:

  • "Decent ice cream, horrible customer service."
  • "Rude cashier and poor customer service."
  • "Staff was kinda rude, tbh."
  • "The guy at the cashier gave the vibes that we annoy him with our presence a bit…lol"
  • "The service was fast with absolutely no wait time at all!!."
  • "The ice cream taiyaki is good ice cream but mediocre taiyaki."
  • "Pretty overrated."

Shop Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "This taiyaki and ice cream shop is well worth the trek into Chinatown."
  • "This tiny, adorable shop offers quick service and a clean atmosphere."
  • "The atmosphere of the ice cream shop is very oriental and relaxing, ideal for a break after a day spent in the city."
  • "The vibe is very upbeat and energetic and that comes through in the presentation and product."
  • "This small but mighty spot is the perfect place to enjoy something sweet and feel like you are truly enjoying a little slice of Asian culture."
  • "It was a plus to have the staff be knowledgable because certain days you are in the mood for something sweet, tarty or chocolate-y."
  • "The ambiance is a typical ice cream shop."

Cons:

  • "Little tiny place so not the place you can seat down."
  • "The place didn't even have a half-decent place to sit. Very disappointing."
  • "Not a lot of seating available, only a small bench and table outside and nothing indoors."
  • "They have little to no seating as the place is tiny."
  • "There isn't much space to dine in and have your ice cream."
  • "There is no space in the restaurant, and with how crowded it gets, you’ll be standing next to a bunch of people."
  • "There is no space to seat and eat your ice cream."

Price and Value

Pros:

  • "Only $8! Much cheaper than other places here in NYC."
  • "All the Taiyaki comes with two toppings, so if you want to add more, it will cost you 50 cents per topping, which is pretty cheap."
  • "It was very affordable and came with toppings."
  • "Finally got to try these! Waited on the line for about under 1 hour. So light and fluffy, very flavorful! Only $8! Much cheaper than other places here in NYC, & they were the first to bring it to NYC!"
  • "Stopped in after lunch with my girlfriend and got another reliably perfect traditional taiyaki with red-bean paste for an extremely thoughtful price."

Cons:

  • "The unicorn taro tea floats were delicious, though pricy."
  • "I would give a 4.5 stars if I could only because the pricing is a bit high."
  • "It's slightly pricey; the venue is tight and gets crowded quickly; $10 minimum for cards."
  • "The ice cream was good but not good enough to buy it for $8-$9."
  • "You pay almost $10 for a machine made ice cream on top of a fish shaped waffle."
  • "Only downside I could give is it was a little pricey for ice cream but well worth it."
  • "Yes, the price is a bit high for the portion size."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.