Eveready Diner Reviews Summary

Category: Diner

Address: 4184 Albany Post Rd, Hyde Park, NY 12538, USA

Phone: +18452298100

Rating: 4.3
based on 352 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Our waitress was very friendly and sweet and I loved the retro design."
  • "Eggs were cooked perfectly, the strawberry butter is a nice touch as well as the decorative slice of cantaloupe along with every dish and the service was great!"
  • "A wonderfully attentive waitstaff, thank you Jimmy."
  • "They seem attentive to social distancing with outdoor tables, fewer tables inside and staff wears masks."
  • "The food was great. Service was just as good."
  • "Our waitress, Kayla, was super friendly and helpful with the menu."
  • "The wait staff that has been at the diner for a long period of time are always pleasant and willing to go the extra mile."

Cons:

  • "There was no eye to eye contact between the server and myself."
  • "Waitstaff was decent, but was frequently M.I.A. when needing drink refills!"
  • "Took almost 15 minutes for server to come to our table."
  • "The kids that work there are more interested in flirting with guests than serving food."
  • "The food was a little bit cold, the server was not very attentive."
  • "Won't ever go back."
  • "Either cook isn't good or it was sitting for awhile because not only cold but steak was well and eggs were hard."

Cleanliness

Pros:

  • "Clean bathrooms."
  • "They seem attentive to social distancing with outdoor tables, fewer tables inside and staff wears masks."
  • "Very clean facilities and courteous staff."
  • "Chrome everywhere and not a fingerprint to be seen."
  • "Easy to find and get to. The diner was a little worn but everything was very clean."
  • "Clean establishment with a very friendly staff."
  • "Food is always fast, consistent and tasty."

Cons:

  • "But the place was filthy."
  • "The place was very cool a few years ago but is showing it's age."
  • "The ceiling tiles had the full color of the rainbow, but was mold."
  • "We couldn't ignore how dirty it was. All our utensils were dirty. Table and seats were dirty. Under the table was dirty. Bathrooms - dirty."
  • "The diner is filthy!!!!! The floors were sticky and dirty."
  • "The restaurant was grungy and in desperate need of a deep clean."
  • "Interesting decor, but getting a little dirty. Water stained ceiling tiles should really be replaced."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Eggs were cooked perfectly, the strawberry butter is a nice touch as well as the decorative slice of cantaloupe along with every dish and the service was great!"
  • "The burgers, salads and pancakes were good."
  • "Big selection and always a great meal!"
  • "The food was great. Service was just as good."
  • "The fish was cooked perfectly, the fried were awesome, the tartar sauce and coleslaw were perfect; even the lemons were juicy."
  • "Breakfast was a wild western omelet. Which was huge portions with a huge sign of potatoes. Pretty tasty."
  • "The dinner food is reliably good and comforting."

Cons:

  • "The quality of the experience at this diner has always been hit or miss for me and in the past year the quality of the food has declined to the point I wont be back ever again."
  • "Lately, when we try to treat ourselves with eating out, we're always disappointed."
  • "The food was a little bit cold, the server was not very attentive."
  • "Either cook isn't good or it was sitting for awhile because not only cold but steak was well and eggs were hard."
  • "The chili I ordered was 'ok,' but the chicken soup and grill cheese were grade A. The home fries were bland."
  • "The sausage they served had no flavor whatsoever. The home fries were greasy."
  • "Eggs were undercooked and hollandaise was definitely not made in house."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.