Westchester Diner Reviews Summary

Category: Diner

Address: 300 Albany Post Rd, Peekskill, NY 10566, USA

Phone: +19147344949

Rating: 4.0
based on 137 reviews.

Menu

Pros:

  • "The menu diverse."
  • "The menu is different with wonderful choices."
  • "Their menu is large, but everything is good."
  • "The food is always great."
  • "The portions are good for the cost and delicious if I may say so again."
  • "The food was just as good as I remembered."
  • "The new management did a great job of keeping all the good stuff and just adding other good stuff."

Cons:

  • "I’ve gotten three bad meals on a row."
  • "Menu is adequate, nothing special."
  • "The menu has shrunk and burgers and breakfast fare are pretty much the only good things left."
  • "There menu is so small not to many option you would get at a diner."
  • "BUT the prices are so very much higher...fine restaurant higher for a diner."
  • "Ordered a Cobb salad and ended up getting a garden salad with croutons. No chicken no bacon no anything!!!"
  • "Bacon in BLT not fully cooked."

Service

Pros:

  • "Nice place to hangout, our waiter (I think his name was Edgar) was super accommodating."
  • "The staff was so attentive and friendly, especially the manager!"
  • "The waitress Aura was super helpful and nice."
  • "Service was great."
  • "Our waiter was funny, friendly, professional, and attentive."
  • "The staff were attentive, friendly, and quick to serve."
  • "The service was incredible. Friendly and attentive waiter."

Cons:

  • "Service was prompt considering they messed up my order."
  • "The waiter was not the best, our order was all wrong."
  • "Service was slow with only 4 people in the whole place...just awful."
  • "Poor customer service at front desk."
  • "Got upcharged sneakily on some fries."
  • "The waiter was extremely rude."
  • "The service was very inattentive and slow to take an order and get the check."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The food came out quick, hot, and well made."
  • "Onion rings were extra good."
  • "The food of course, delicious."
  • "Comfort food and great prices!"
  • "The chicken soup and Bacon Cheeseburger was excellent."
  • "The turkey tasted great, texture was on point."
  • "Food was flavourful."

Cons:

  • "Burger was supposed to be medium rare... But this thing was still mooing."
  • "The burger bun was so ordinary. The philly steak meat was dry."
  • "The food after all that time was less than mediocre."
  • "The omlet did not taste good."
  • "The Cobb salad wasn't up to par."
  • "This was probably the worst wrap I have tasted."
  • "The food was unseasoned, and everything we got was either over or undercooked."

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "Nice, clean, no frills diner, family-friendly environment."
  • "And the bathrooms were very clean."
  • "For a diner it does not get to noisy affecting your tables/booths conversation."
  • "The service and atmosphere was excellent."
  • "The diner is nice, good location off the highway."
  • "The atmosphere busy diner crowd."
  • "The food, service, music, and atmosphere was perfect."

Cons:

  • "Not much room for strollers; I'd recommend leaving it in the car."
  • "Never, ever, ever order delivery from this place on grubhub."
  • "It's decent. I have had MUCH better from other diners."
  • "Something's off with this place. It's not how it used to be, it's so gloomy and quiet and barely anyone there now."
  • "Their prices are out of bounds...no air conditioning."
  • "This is a very busy diner, so also very noisy inside making it difficult to have a conversation."
  • "Extremely lacking atmosphere."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.