Prospector's Steakhouse & Saloon Reviews Summary

Service

Pros:

• "Service was on point, very pleasant and attentive (Miranda🤗)"
• "Our server Michael was fantastic. Attentive, fun and honest about wait times."
• "The waitress was attentive and present, which I find to be, quite often, a rarity at restaurants."
• "Jason the waiter was great. He anticipated our needs and was there when we wanted him."
• "Staff is super friendly."
• "Our waitress, Jenn, was fantastic!"
• "Our server Marion S. was a great server.. Punctual and pleasant.."

Cons:

• "Our server took our empty basket of rolls and never replenished them or asked if we wanted more."
• "Bartenders are rude and have no customer service skills training."
• "Our initial server never stopped by our table to check on us."
• "We waited extremely long for our drinks."
• "Our waiter never came around, so we asked the busboy how the buffet works and how to get drinks."
• "Server was uninterested and never offered to refill drinks."
• "Service was slow, but there was only one bartender for that bar, and all the tables!"

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food is excellent, although when I was there, the salad bar was not available, and I was disappointed about that."
• "Very reasonably priced entrees."
• "The homemade soups and chili were delicious."
• "Oh yeah the food was really good. And the portions was big."
• "The food was delicious."
• "Food is delicious. Their dinner rolls are awesome."
• "The food was very good. I suggest you try the omelette bar."

Cons:

• "Underneath the tables were caked in gum."
• "Couldn't get the drink orders right. Bugs on the salad plate. Bug in the bread basket."
• "All the lettuce was brown."
• "The steaks are just BAD Either too fatty or too much grizzle."
• "The soup sucked.. & a $25 shrimp dinner sucked.."
• "The burger I ordered was just ok."
• "Expensive bland $28.45 for pork chops one person."

Ambience

Pros:

• "The atmosphere was Bonanza Steakhouse level."
• "That said, the proportions were massive."
• "The decor in this place is really cool!"
• "Great ambience indeed."
• "Absolutely awesome decor and atmosphere!"
• "Western atmosphere, rustic wood booths, lots of western pics on the walls."
• "The atmosphere was also very charming and southern."

Cons:

• "The windows looked like they hadn't been dusted in months."
• "Their not caring enough to deep clean during a pandemic. Is so disrespectful."
• "The place is getting dated and less cleanly."
• "It was so dirty in the bar area."
• "The outdoor room looks a bit run down.. the glass doors had a bunch of scotch tape, there were tacky vinyl posters over the fireplace."
• "The carpeted floor looks so worn out and a dirty brown."
• "Dirt and dust spider webs every were please take a broom to the wall with a damp rag and clean, darn."

Price

Pros:

• "4 people with our sodas/lemonade under $100."
• "It's a great place for seniors where the menu is not overwhelming, the staff are patient and the layout of the restaurant is welcoming."
• "The all you can eat soup and salad bar lunch special is the best lunch deal in South Jersey."
• "Great value for the $ spent."
• "The food was amazing, staff was generous and we never needed to ask for anything."
• "The portions are huge definitely & worth the price. Go hungry!"
• "Food was very tasty. Not that expensive."

Cons:

• "Spent 160.00 and had to take the family too McDonald’s before our movie."
• "Our tab for 3 w1 salad bar, 2 dinners + 1 salad bar add on, 1 appetizer w/2 drinks (1 a draft beer special).. over $155 w/tip.."
• "Very disappointed that the price for Mother's Day Buffett was not noted anywhere in the building, but when the bill came it was $35 a plate."
• "With tip, I spent $55!!! We had the buffet with coffee, $45! I tipped $10 because the service was excellent."
• "Salad bar left much to be desired @ $22.. Ruby Tuesday has better & more abundant greens & just as much selection @ $11.99.."
• "It stinks paying for a salad with meat that you can't eat!"
• "For 17.99 per person, drinks not included, having to tip the omelet and waffle guy's and a buffet that was half of what it used to be made our visit less than pleasurable."