The Galley Pizza & Eatery Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "They have the best pizza on the shore."
• "Creative menu, and delicious food!"
• "The ingredients were fresh, the burrata melts in your mouth and the hot honey sauce adds another element to the experience eating this pie."
• "The smoked prime rib cheesesteak is absolutely amazing."
• "Food was the best I had in the area! So different and delicious, all locally grown and no harmful ingredients."
• "The crust is thin and perfectly crispy and there was an even distribution of sauce and cheese."
• "The food had so much flavor, so fresh tasting."

Cons:

• "Pizza was always good until tonight."
• "Chicken tenders were very bland, overcooked, and had far more breading than actual chicken."
• "It was ice cold the pasta was overcooked."
• "The food was okay but way over-priced."
• "Some of the pizzas cost well over $30."
• "We just picked up a pizza that is inedible! The crust is black! Very burnt!"
• "The fries were good and would've tasted better Hot they were Cold!!"

Service

Pros:

• "The staff was spot on and friendly."
• "The people working here are very nice and they know exactly what they are doing."
• "Young lady who helped me at the counter was very pleasant and had a great smile which is always nice to see in an establishment."
• "The service was great as well, we had a nice waitress who was very helpful in choosing a pie."
• "The service staff was also super friendly and helpful with our questions/requests for our order."
• "Chris even went so far to text me information I needed to help fix this situation."
• "The staff is extremely attentive, and even surprised us with an appetizer - fried mozzarella with fresh sauce on the side (must try.)"

Cons:

• "Evidently, they made a mistake, but no explanation or apology."
• "Didn’t take our name or phone number. Then proceeded to sit another 2 before us."
• "After waiting for that long to be told that my food was ready the whole time but no one could find my car which was right in front for a curbside pickup."
• "Service is much too slow, unfortunately."
• "I ordered a delivery today around 5:40 today. They told me around an hour and 30 minutes wait. It’s currently 8:10 and more than 2 hours later and I have still not gotten the food."
• "Ordered delivery at 6:30 pm and the pizza showed up at 9:15 pm."
• "Giving up on Galley. Ordered on app, order was wrong late and waited 30 mins in store for a total of 1 hr."

Atmosphere

Pros:

• "Atmosphere was pretty cool for a pizzeria with funny signs and nice people."
• "The place has a really cool island vibe."
• "The aesthetics are so Asbury!"
• "Atmosphere fun and inviting."
• "The vibes are awesome here! I love the old marina vibes."
• "The inside is just a great hangout."
• "The atmosphere is almost redeeming though, somewhere between a Pizza Hut and The Hyatt lobby."

Cons:

• "Only thing is that it’s a little tight and you may be sitting very next to people where you can easily overhear conversations."
• "Music far too loud to have a conversation without shouting."
• "The music was pounding out way too loud."
• "The music was on REALLY LOUD."
• "Located in a very small space, every time the door opened, a cold wind blew through the place."
• "Customers come in and out so if you sit by the door and it’s winter, you will be cold."
• "A lady setting up chairs for the soon to open shop, gave us a hard time about parking in front of a store that isn't even open for service."

Value

Pros:

• "The price is reasonable for the great quality you get."
• "Whether you pick up or eat in the food is amazing."
• "Their delivery service was excellent as well and my food was delivered when I was told it would arrive."
• "The ingredients were fresh, the presentation was nice."
• "Everything is made to order with fresh ingredients."
• "The servers are very welcoming."
• "The staff is amazingly friendly and the inside is just a great hangout."

Cons:

• "Well cheesesteak was listed $20, server charged me $22 PLUS charges an $1 for onions & peppers?"
• "Asked for grated cheese and they wanted to charge me $3."
• "The bill includes a mystery service fee."
• "For $32 for a small pie I was expecting the best gluten and dairy free pizza of my life."
• "I ask for ketchup and was charged additional .50 for it!"
• "The owner of this establishment has attacked me online for stating my opinion and left me a rude Facebook message accusing me of lying."
• "The guy decided to publicly shame me on social media without even calling me, seeing what happened or anything."