"Everything is delicious serving everything from steaks, pizza, sandwiches, sushi seafood, appetizers, etc."
"Not only was the food of high quality and great taste, the service was great."
"The food is amazing! Literally everything I've had (and that's a lot) is amazing!"
"The crab bisque and chicken parm soup are delicious."
"Ordered the NY steak, fantastic."
"The penne with shrimp was rich and creamy."
"Everything we ordered was delicious, hot, and fresh."
Cons:
"Always good food until they served me a burned hard rubber bloomin onion and then had the nerve to charge for that garbage."
"The sides were lacking and bland."
"Had a grilled chicken sandwich from the takeout window and it was dry and didn't have any taste."
"Food runner was clueless, server was inattentive, and food was horrible."
"The pretzel roll was ice cold and hard, the burger was well done."
"Rib eye was tasteless."
"The fish was pale brown/grey, oily, had no crunchy crispy outer shell to it whatsoever."
Service
Pros:
"Servers are friendly and attentive."
"Servers are always friendly at this popular bar/restaurant."
"The servers and workers are always polite and on the ball."
"Our server went above and beyond."
"Service was quick and friendly."
"The staff are great here and always very helpful and pleasant."
"Our server was pleasant and attentive."
Cons:
"Service was good just slow but the place was mobbed so totally understandable about slower service."
"Food has always been good but we'll never be back, the service was horrible and the way my daughter was treated at the front door because she has a tattoo was inexcusable, very disappointed in their close mindedness."
"TERRIBLE TERRIBLE SERVICE!!!"
"The hostess&manager? We’re not friendly."
"Non attentive...server was absolutely horrible!"
"The waitress never took the salad plates and soup bowls off the table so the whole time we ate the table was crowded with dirty plates."
"Service is slow and prices are high."
Atmosphere
Pros:
"This bar burned down and they rebuilt bigger and better."
"So good to see Caffreys back in business."
"The atmosphere is always warm and welcoming."
"They are also doing a great job with precautions and social distancing."
"Great food, great atmosphere."
"The place was packed and had a great atmosphere."
"Cool atmosphere, open air with outdoor seating."
Cons:
"It can sometimes get a little loud inside the restaurant on the bar side."
"Crowded, so whatever they are doing apparently works here for them; however not a place I would go out of my way to go a second time to. Very noisy ambiance."
"Very noisy by the 55 TV's bar... can't hear TV, or conversation."
"It was a Friday so it was very noisy and busy."
"It's a very busy loud rambunctious crowd so if you're looking for a quiet place, keep moving lol."