Americana Diner Reviews Summary

Category: American restaurant Middletown, New York

Address: 420 East, 420 NY-211, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

Phone: +18453446060

Rating: 4.3
based on 251 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "Even though they were very busy our waitress was very attentive and quick to check on us."
  • "Service was excellent, with Angela (our waitress) masterfully caring for 10 people as of it were 2."
  • "The server was very friendly and took great care of us."
  • "Our waitress was wonderful."
  • "Service is decent and friendly."
  • "Service was good."
  • "Our waitress, whose name was Michelle, she was very polite and friendly and a very good server."

Cons:

  • "Our waitress had no time for us in an empty place."
  • "Service was extremely slow, once ordered."
  • "Inconsistent food quality and service."
  • "The food was excellent the service was by far lacking."
  • "Bad service ... I ordered two sirloin steak and one came without one of the sides I ordered (french fries)."
  • "Our only issue was the blonde waitress we had was terrible."
  • "Service was extremely slow and awful. Took over a half hour to get a drink...and another half hour to get a burger."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food was great, very nice portion size thanks for that."
  • "The food is always good and they give you a good amount and service is fine."
  • "Portions are big."
  • "Great comfort food with amazing breakfast offerings."
  • "Always good food and service here."
  • "Very good food with large portions and variety... Prices very reasonable."
  • "The food was served quick and it was delicious."

Cons:

  • "Food quality issues 2x in a row, now my wife has food poisoning from bad egg salad."
  • "Cobb salad nothing but sad ice berg lettuce."
  • "The food wasn't as good as it use to be."
  • "Lettuce 🥬 in my plate looked like was taken out of a dumpster."
  • "Had eggplant wrap and was soggy with no taste."
  • "The food was tasteless as well, never again."
  • "My children ordered pancakes and they tasted sour."

Cleanliness

Pros:

  • "We were welcomed by a friendly staff at the Diner, who went out of their way to make us feel welcome."
  • "Proper hygeine and protection by staff via masks."
  • "The place is clean and well lit like a diner."
  • "The tables are clean, the bathrooms are clean, the restaurant overall is clean."
  • "Place is clean & they'll allow you to choose your seat."
  • "Always fresh because it's a busy spot."
  • "This diner is so pretty, big and clean."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.