Address: 201 N Dupont Hwy, New Castle, DE 19720, USA
Phone: +13023226222
Rating: 4.3
based on 219 reviews.
Food Quality
Pros:
"The decaf coffee was the best of any restaurant I've been to."
"We had the most amazing dinner, seafood bisque was out of this world."
"Might be the best French toast!"
"The food is always great."
"The food was amazing I went with my dad we both thoroughly enjoyed our food."
"The food is delicious!"
"The food was really tasty. We had a variety of foods i.e. Ravioli, Alfredo Pasta, Burger, Reuben, and Country Fried Steak."
Cons:
"Food was good but a little bland for my taste."
"Food was certainly not worth the price."
"Was not impressed with food quality."
"The food was not steaming the potatoes were raw and the sausage had a sour taste."
"Don't get the veggie skillet. Canned or frozen spinach, canned mushrooms, overcooked potatoes."
"The crab cakes were puny not have much flavor."
"Food lousy, I got chicken alfredo with broccoli chicken wasn't done."
Service
Pros:
"Our server was spot on, and the bathroom was very clean."
"Waiter Luis was very nice, apologized when he saw it and took it off the bill."
"Friendly staff, quick service, great food."
"Our waitress Judy is great she is down to earth and she is always pleasant."
"Food was delicious, service was fast, this could possibly be my new go to."
"Food was amazing and the service was awesome."
"Our very nice server kept the cups filled while all was being cooked."
Cons:
"Sad way to treat Dan and elderly man."
"I requested a discount he than got upset."
"The service which it's not busy was bad the waitress walked passed me a couple times and didn't ask me anything."
"Waited for over 15 minutes for a server."
"Wait staff tries to be attentive but I’ve seen them covering too many tables at once many times."
"When I went to pay my bill, the young girl ringing me out asked how everything was, to which I responded 'horrible actually'. Her response to me was 'that sucks'."
"The waitress chased to to my car to tell me I did not leave enough."
Value
Pros:
"They offer discounts for seniors and veterans."
"$50 for a party of 3 with drinks isn't bad at all."
"Good value for the price."
"Prices are reasonable."
"Great desserts at great prices."
"The baked goods are large servings."
"Quick polite service, great menu selection, huge portions, VERY reasonable prices."
Cons:
"There food is over priced and the food is tasteless."
"9.00 for a bowl of chili is ridiculous."
"Overpriced meals and mediocre food quality."
"The food tasted ok, but very expensive!"
"$32.xx for this does not seem like a bargain or a fair price to me."
"With a beverage it was $22.40. Not worth the money in my opinion."
"They charge almost the same money as Schaefer’s in Chesapeake City, for their seafood items and the quality suffers considerably."
Ambiance
Pros:
"The new owners have really cleaned up the inside."
"Old style diner fare... Lots of tasty things on the menu."
"Very nice place to meet 3 other friends. Quite nostalgic since this was built on the site that was once the Peter Pan Diner."
"Great atmosphere felt like home in Jersey."
"The Legend is better... very clean!"
"It is beautiful on the inside."
"The updates to the building are gorgeous."
Cons:
"We were asked to wear mask inbetween eating and drinking because another customer didn't like the fact we had children who where eating without mask."
"It's very difficult to enjoy a meal while removing and replacing a mask In between drinks and bites."
"Yellow paint they used is a little much, tone it down some."
"The atmosphere does not exist."
"The manager was rude and ignorant."
"The owner definitely has a chip on his shoulder and I don't support businesses that argue with a customer's."
"Management unfortunately lacks compassion and care for their customers."