The Grill at The Pittstown Inn Reviews Summary

Food Quality

Pros:

• "The food is great and the building is a really nice piece of history."
• "The food is out of this world and the service is impeccable!"
• "Best restaurant in Hunterdon County. Dining room is beautiful, service exceptional and food scrumptious."
• "Not only is the food incredible but the staff is incredible as well."
• "Great food, professional staff in a historic inn with attention to detail makes the Pittstown Inn a Five Star establishment."
• "Food is delicious and the atmosphere charming."
• "The food is consistently delicious, whether I choose something from the regular menu or order one of the specials."

Cons:

• "We sat outside and got attacked by swarms of flies."
• "Lobster bisque soup was lukewarm; I had the surf & turf, the surf was tough and chewy."
• "The very stringy steak was tough, so I had to undercut it against the grain thinly to make it easy to eat."
• "The food was mediocre at best."
• "The seafood dishes we ordered for entrees, salmon and scallops, were perfectly cooked."
• "Surf and Turf for $46 a plate consisted of a filet mignon with ONE scallop and ONE shrimp."
• "The roast turkey breast was thickly sliced turkey loaf, nearly tasteless and dry."

Service

Pros:

• "The employees were friendly and went above and beyond."
• "Incredible service."
• "Our waiter was absolutely wonderful, attentive and polite."
• "Service like that goes long way and for sure we will be back."
• "Service could not have been better."
• "The service was outstanding!!"
• "The wait staff was attentive and gracious."

Cons:

• "Three drinks before we went to our table cost almost 70 bucks."
• "More than expected truck traffic occasionally interfered with conversation."
• "Had a good meal server came to the table after a 10 minute wait. Hardly ever to be seen again."
• "The waiter was HITTING ON MY FIANCÉ."
• "He immediately assumed a defensively rude position and an intimidating demeanor."
• "Very slow service and abrupt conversation with our current waiter who we had a very hard time understanding."
• "He angrily followed my wife to the bathroom, and then he harassed me aggressively."

Ambiance

Pros:

• "The atmosphere is cozy and comfortable but at the same time upscale and elegant."
• "Incredibly beautiful from the outside and big parking lot across from it. Inside it's very intimate setting."
• "Service and overall atmosphere is good."
• "A truly lovely evening. Thank you!"
• "Very peaceful quiet place to relax and have a great 1on 1 conversation with a loved one."
• "Love this place for a Saturday night! The space is rustic and still elegant."
• "The restaurant itself is charming and beautiful, and they make you feel like you’re a VIP when you’re there."

Cons:

• "The only downside is that noise travels and a loud group sat in our same area. There were times when we could not hear."
• "However it was so uncomfortable hot in the restaurant."
• "More than expected truck traffic occasionally interfered with conversation."
• "Parking is across the busy main street of Pittstown."
• "The burger was terrible."
• "The calamari was unappetizing."
• "The desserts were fair at best... the mud pie was dry and grainy, more like sand pie."

Value

Pros:

• "The prices are around the $25-$35 range. However it's big portions and good food."
• "The staff is very polite and friendly, the food is absolutely tasty and best of all the prices are extremely reasonable or maybe a little underpriced."
• "As usual the food was delicious, the drinks were great."
• "I wish I could I could give this restaurant a hundred stars."
• "The food is outstanding and very flavorful."
• "The owner and staff were beyond attentive."
• "The staff are all friendly and attentive."

Cons:

• "Three drinks before we went to our table cost almost 70 bucks."
• "Next, we were very surprised to find that in just a matter of a few weeks, prices were increasing yet portions getting even smaller!"
• "Way overpriced for the quality of the food."
• "Only problem was the scallops were a special and cost $42, very overpriced."
• "5 star prices for Applebee's food."
• "I probably won't go back for dinner ($$$$) but I'll try a lunch and beer and let y'all know."
• "The food was not what would be expected for paying that price."