The Hill Reviews Summary

Category: American restaurant

Address: 252 Schraalenburgh Rd, Closter, NJ 07624, USA

Phone: +12018994700

Rating: 4.4
based on 145 reviews.

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "The ambiance of this place is pretty amazing."
  • "This restaurant is absolutely beautiful inside and out."
  • "Amazing restaurant! Beautiful dining room, bar is great."
  • "Beautiful place, we went there for a baby shower, the staff, and decor was 5 star!"
  • "Its inside combines modern contemporary design with exposed brick, reclaimed wood and warm palletes which create a cozy yet stylish environment."
  • "The atmosphere is very cozy in the summer, and I'm sure the fireplace makes it really a great feeling in the winter."
  • "The atmosphere, staff, and food were all terrific."

Cons:

  • "Also their decorations are so cheap. Fake candles and plants like c’mon, seriously?"
  • "Some of the tables for 2 are VERY close together."
  • "Felt like seating could be spread out a bit more as the tables next to us were quite close."
  • "A great hangout place maybe not the best if you are POC."
  • "Sat us by the kitchen."
  • "The bar was not capable of making simple cocktails."
  • "The place is nice and the atmosphere is excellent."

Service

Pros:

  • "Jensen and Andrew were responsive and accommodating in the planning process leading up to the Wedding."
  • "The staff at The Hill are terrific."
  • "Overall 5/5, ambience and service also fantastic."
  • "Lauren, who is the event Director literally did everything with precision and perfection!"
  • "Frank, one of the managers, cared for and tended to our every need as the bride and groom."
  • "The service from Jeff and his colleagues were very good."
  • "The staff was super attentive, but not intrusive."

Cons:

  • "The gentlemen said no, rather arrogantly."
  • "The service this time around was really rough."
  • "The waiter never refilled our water."
  • "The service was poor as our server was missing and unavailable during our entire visit."
  • "We had to call our waiter several times and each time we called her she turned the other way and ignored us."
  • "However, the service was horrendous! I asked the waiter for some bread, after 15 minutes, i asked again because it never came."
  • "Our server was detached, slow and fairly inattentive."

Food

Pros:

  • "Got the 'perfect Gin & Tonic'. Gotta say it, in fact, was perfect."
  • "The food was delicious. My family was raving about it."
  • "The gnocchi was like eating a cloud."
  • "Food was phenomenal."
  • "The food was cooked with fresh ingredients and was tasty and delicious."
  • "The best meal we have had in years!!!!!"
  • "The food was very good. I ordered the calamari to start. It was fresh and very light batter."

Cons:

  • "OVERPRICED! The setting is beautiful. Plenty of room at the bar. Such a shame the food is sooo pricey and was okay at best."
  • "Overly priced and food was less then generic, bland no flavor and under cooked."
  • "The subpar quality of the food led me to write a review, something I haven't done for years."
  • "The flank steak had no flavor to it."
  • "The food was a huge flop."
  • "The food looked great, but man was it bland."
  • "My medium rare steak WAS A FREAKING HOCKEY PUCK!!!"

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.