Rosie's Trattoria Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant Randolph, New Jersey

Address: 1181 Sussex Turnpike, Randolph, NJ 07869, USA

Phone: +19738953434

Rating: 4.5
based on 167 reviews.

Atmosphere

Pros:

  • "The restaurant itself, is very inviting and comfortable."
  • "The dining area beyond the lively bar possesses a certain elegance which is uniquely balanced with the coziness you'd experience in your Grandma's kitchen."
  • "The ambiance was great too!"
  • "The atmosphere is very welcoming!"
  • "Rosie's has a very nice atmosphere."
  • "The ambience was cozy and welcoming."
  • "Upon entering, you're met with a vibe that is distinctly Old World Europe- the style is Tuscan-inspired."

Cons:

  • "Venue was a little noisy (even with the noise absorbers on the wall) and tables were close to one another."
  • "Way too loud up there."
  • "It was nice however loud with the amount of people seated together."
  • "But it was so loud upstairs I couldn't wait to leave."
  • "Also because of the reflective surfaces in the small dining area we were in it was very noisy."
  • "The room we sat in was very noisy. Hard to have a conversation in."
  • "On almost any weekend night, the bar is packed and a bit loud!"

Service

Pros:

  • "Service was very attentive."
  • "The staff is very friendly and so attentive."
  • "They are very professional and nice and will fix anything for you so that’s great."
  • "The service is exceptional."
  • "The service was top notch, and all of the servers and front of the house staff were cheerful and attentive."
  • "The staff had a great attitude and were trying to accommodate everyone as fast they could."
  • "The service here is top notch!"

Cons:

  • "Service speed may vary at times but is attentive and friendly."
  • "The service was below average."
  • "Ultimately the service was horrible."
  • "The service was good but the servers were rude."
  • "It just felt like we paid a lot of money to wait for mediocre food and subpar service."
  • "Each time the service has been very poor."
  • "Our service was slow and inattentive from beginning to end."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Both dishes were good/above average but neither was excellent."
  • "Everything we had was amazing."
  • "The Penne Vodka was some of the best I’ve had in awhile."
  • "The food is absolutely delicious & worth the price."
  • "Always fresh always cooked to perfection."
  • "The food was amazing. Everything was fresh and delicious."
  • "The food is always delicious."

Cons:

  • "The appetizers were not as impressive as the entrees the meatballs were slightly tough."
  • "The chicken Parmesan breading was a little mushy with the bread crumbs on the outside."
  • "The food tastes like it came out of a can or a frozen package."
  • "The salmon Dijon was very salty, the mashed potatoes were seasoned well and the vegetables were not seasoned at all."
  • "The food was not at all appetizing."
  • "The entrees tasted like the food had been frozen for months at the bottom of the freezer and microwaved on defrost."
  • "The chicken came out very thick and had no taste."

Value

Pros:

  • "Given the pricing, you expect well above average."
  • "In my opinion the food was priced right for the quality."
  • "Highly impressive, fresh, and impeccable quality meal for a fantastic price."
  • "Unbelievable food for an amazing price."
  • "Pricing was fair and true to the two $$ advertised on google, not overly priced for portions."
  • "Food very good and reasonable."
  • "Pleasantly surprised and competitively priced."

Cons:

  • "However, I think the food has suffered since then and the food prices have gotten more expensive."
  • "Overprice and not worth the money we paid."
  • "Just so not worth it for the price we should have kept our reservation at capital grill."
  • "Overpriced and mediocre at best."
  • "All the steaks were pricey."
  • "Portions are small and overpriced in my opinion."
  • "But it’s Way over priced."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.