Address: 1181 Sussex Turnpike, Randolph, NJ 07869, USA
Phone: +19738953434
Rating: 4.5
based on 167 reviews.
Atmosphere
Pros:
"The restaurant itself, is very inviting and comfortable."
"The dining area beyond the lively bar possesses a certain elegance which is uniquely balanced with the coziness you'd experience in your Grandma's kitchen."
"The ambiance was great too!"
"The atmosphere is very welcoming!"
"Rosie's has a very nice atmosphere."
"The ambience was cozy and welcoming."
"Upon entering, you're met with a vibe that is distinctly Old World Europe- the style is Tuscan-inspired."
Cons:
"Venue was a little noisy (even with the noise absorbers on the wall) and tables were close to one another."
"Way too loud up there."
"It was nice however loud with the amount of people seated together."
"But it was so loud upstairs I couldn't wait to leave."
"Also because of the reflective surfaces in the small dining area we were in it was very noisy."
"The room we sat in was very noisy. Hard to have a conversation in."
"On almost any weekend night, the bar is packed and a bit loud!"
Service
Pros:
"Service was very attentive."
"The staff is very friendly and so attentive."
"They are very professional and nice and will fix anything for you so that’s great."
"The service is exceptional."
"The service was top notch, and all of the servers and front of the house staff were cheerful and attentive."
"The staff had a great attitude and were trying to accommodate everyone as fast they could."
"The service here is top notch!"
Cons:
"Service speed may vary at times but is attentive and friendly."
"The service was below average."
"Ultimately the service was horrible."
"The service was good but the servers were rude."
"It just felt like we paid a lot of money to wait for mediocre food and subpar service."
"Each time the service has been very poor."
"Our service was slow and inattentive from beginning to end."
Food Quality
Pros:
"Both dishes were good/above average but neither was excellent."
"Everything we had was amazing."
"The Penne Vodka was some of the best I’ve had in awhile."
"The food is absolutely delicious & worth the price."
"Always fresh always cooked to perfection."
"The food was amazing. Everything was fresh and delicious."
"The food is always delicious."
Cons:
"The appetizers were not as impressive as the entrees the meatballs were slightly tough."
"The chicken Parmesan breading was a little mushy with the bread crumbs on the outside."
"The food tastes like it came out of a can or a frozen package."
"The salmon Dijon was very salty, the mashed potatoes were seasoned well and the vegetables were not seasoned at all."
"The food was not at all appetizing."
"The entrees tasted like the food had been frozen for months at the bottom of the freezer and microwaved on defrost."
"The chicken came out very thick and had no taste."
Value
Pros:
"Given the pricing, you expect well above average."
"In my opinion the food was priced right for the quality."
"Highly impressive, fresh, and impeccable quality meal for a fantastic price."
"Unbelievable food for an amazing price."
"Pricing was fair and true to the two $$ advertised on google, not overly priced for portions."
"Food very good and reasonable."
"Pleasantly surprised and competitively priced."
Cons:
"However, I think the food has suffered since then and the food prices have gotten more expensive."
"Overprice and not worth the money we paid."
"Just so not worth it for the price we should have kept our reservation at capital grill."
"Overpriced and mediocre at best."
"All the steaks were pricey."
"Portions are small and overpriced in my opinion."