"The best Neapolitan pizza I've eaten in the United States."
"The fried pizza was out of this world! The dough was light and soft on the inside and perfectly crispy on the outside."
"For dessert, you must try the Delizia AL Limone, my gosh, the cake is so soft and delectable."
"The food is just another level of flavor experience!!!"
"The pizza crust was delicious! It was nice and chewy."
"The octopus salad was absolutely amazing."
"The food was amazing (try the Parmigiana pizza it’s to die for!)"
Cons:
"Over priced apps very small portions."
"However, the center of the pizza was soggy."
"Also very small portions."
"Food was good but overpriced."
"The crust wasn't done enough and very soppy."
"Their pizza was okay but their pasta was horrible.. tried the squid ink clam pasta- I think the clams have gone bad that the pasta tasted sour and like rotten fish…"
"The food is awful and tasteless."
Service
Pros:
"Staff was ready with great energy."
"The owner was fantastic and attentive."
"Great service from weekend afternoon staffs!"
"Joy, our waitress was AMAZING!."
"Service is excellent but not intrusive."
"Staff are on point and very accommodating."
"Our server, Carmela was informative, attentive, and friendly."
Cons:
"The waiter Eduardo was the RUDEST waiter I’ve ever come across in my life."
"We were sitting outside and had to go inside to ask for someone to come take our order."
"Placed a Seamless order for this restaurant. Did not know the restaurant was closed when I placed the order."
"If I could give this restaurant a zero I would."
"First of all, as soon as we walked in, the waitress had an attitude like she was having a bad day."
"Service was just ok as they were short staffed."
"Unfortunately the service is slow and disorganized."
Ambiance
Pros:
"Local spot with a NYC vibe."
"The vibe of the place is exactly what you wanted to be on a Saturday night... perfect!"
"This restaurant has a very trendy look that's classy yet casual with very nice decor."
"The place is decorated nicely it feels like you're overseas."
"Beautiful place, super nice and attentive staff."
"The decor is beautiful and modern, what a great addition to Park Avenue."
"The restaurant also has a nice vibe to it and plays fun music."
Cons:
"The music is too loud, the noise only came from the kitchen, and at times I felt overwhelmed especially with some songs that were turned up, there is no good acoustic."
"It gets crowded very easily though."
"I didn't realize how small the inside was, so it was full for our impromptu visit on a Thu evening."
"NY attitude in Rutherford??? Get a grip!"
"Unfortunately not only did you have no qualms about not honoring first come first serve but you didnt seem to have a care in the world you lost guests."
"After leaving the restaurant, me and my friend both got sick and food poisoning."
"There is nothing good about this establishment."
Value
Pros:
"Rutherford closed down the street in front of the restaurant so we ate outside on a beautiful day which was very nice."
"During summer you can also seat outside."
"The food and drinks are a solid 4."
"Everything we had was excellent."
"They use the highest quality of ingredients."
"The taste was incomparable and the perfect temperature."
"The price is fair considering the quality of food."
Cons:
"Just a bit expensive, but being in the US everything is expensive."
"Overall, for takeout, this was crazy expensive."
"We went after new years and they were out of prosciutto???? Never seen that before."
"One thing disappointing is that they were out of most of their desserts."
"From the extra charges and fees, I wouldn't recommend using an ordering service."
"The prices are way too much for pizza!"
"To start, you will be paying NYC prices for your meal, but they quality is there and you will not be disappointed."