Villari's Lakeside Restaurant Reviews Summary

Category: Italian restaurant Sicklerville, Winslow Township, NJ

Address: 2375 Sicklerville Rd, Sicklerville, NJ 08081, USA

Phone: +18562285244

Rating: 4.2
based on 261 reviews.

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "The coconut crusted crab cakes are to die for!"
  • "The best food I ordered the fried mozzarella it’s my favorite."
  • "The food was delicious, especially the crab cake entre seemed to be a favorite."
  • "Food and drinks are phenomenal, I had the steak salad and it was so good!"
  • "He loves the lobster bisque."
  • "The food selection and quality was exceptional."
  • "The food was cooked to perfection."

Cons:

  • "Asparagus was soggy and limp."
  • "Food was not good, we barely got all of our entrees, severely understaffed, even the dessert stunk."
  • "Don't get the Veal Sinatra. Everything was drowned in bland gravy."
  • "The food was overly expensive and not worth the money."
  • "Their main dishes were acceptable but not worth it."
  • "The desert tasted like refrigerator."
  • "The crab meat was fishy tasting."

Service

Pros:

  • "Our waitress did a fantastic job keeping all our random orders together."
  • "A huge thank you to Brittney, Sam and all those who helped serve my family."
  • "The staff were friendly and accommodating."
  • "Roger, our server, was on point in every way."
  • "The bartender's were very polite and service was quick."
  • "Erica was our waitress this time and she was so nice, friendly, and attentive!"
  • "Our server Sal was a delight, attentive, perfect with our orders and very personable!"

Cons:

  • "It took a long time to receive drinks and very few refills."
  • "The 1st manager came and just blamed that it was busy and offered no other help, she had a very poor attitude."
  • "Drinks were not refilled until we were done eating."
  • "The drinks took close to 20 mins to come out."
  • "Waited a hour for my food then manager didn't want to give us a discount."
  • "All night long, my guests complained about poor bar service."
  • "We had to flag down a different attendant for refills."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "I had my daughters engagement celebration on their patio and it was absolutely beautiful!"
  • "The atmosphere was good, the band was good."
  • "The place seemed very nice in the room we were in."
  • "Overall a terrific experience by the lake."
  • "The deck looked cute and fun."
  • "Absolutely beautiful facility."
  • "The atmosphere is warm, welcoming & very organized."

Cons:

  • "This tiki bar is an absolute nightmare."
  • "Cops had to be called."
  • "The place is in need of a serious face-lift. The interior is so dated!"
  • "The lake looked gross."
  • "The tables were way too close to another large party, and the chairs were uncomfortable and felt like they might break."
  • "We entered the Tiki Bar area & immediately the odor of stale beer & garbage permeated the air."
  • "It was so narrow there was barely enough room to get up to use the bathroom."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.