Mountain House Tavern and Grill Reviews Summary

Category: Bar & grill

Address: 19 US-206, Branchville, NJ 07826, USA

Phone: +19732503300

Rating: 4.5
based on 142 reviews.

Service

Pros:

  • "The staff was friendly."
  • "Our bartender really was a star. The service was fantastic."
  • "Our server Bailey was great."
  • "All of the waitresses with respectful polite and knew the menu and how to explain menu items."
  • "The wait staff is friendly and accommodating to your needs."
  • "The staff are absolutely wonderful here as well."
  • "Our waitress (McKenzie) was so personable."

Cons:

  • "The waitress claimed that the chef went home earlier because his wife was having a baby."
  • "Our first stop in we sat at the bar and all of the staff was sitting and they were on their phones, huge pet peeve."
  • "The waitress got very loud and obnoxious and told them they could not order any food making a huge scene in front of all the other customers."
  • "The waitress claimed she thought we were being helped by someone else."
  • "Mentioned it to the waitress and she could care less."
  • "Both employees did not even offer an apology."
  • "The female bartender / waitress was not around at all and when she was, she was very short with us and rude."

Food Quality

Pros:

  • "Food is good."
  • "The specials are always top notch."
  • "Gourmet food at a reasonable price."
  • "Food always reliable with good portions."
  • "Food was amazing, service was very friendly and prices are very reasonable."
  • "The wood-fired pizza at Mountain House Tavern and Grill was an absolute delight!"
  • "The food is fresh and the portions are decent."

Cons:

  • "Food was very bad. Ordered the pastrami sandwich. Came with some sort of soggy brown sauted onions that were oily."
  • "It's way too cold and loud and they have the smallest most expensive menu."
  • "The fish was frozen and thrown in a fryer leaving it over cooked and a good portion inedible."
  • "Very salty and enough pepper to make it unpleasant."
  • "All the burgers were well done. Meat was tasty, but dry."
  • "Small portions, hard pork chops, tasteless fish tacos, half cooked pasta, even the burger was small and greasy."
  • "Was literally hard chicken (that hard that I’m having little cut under my tounge), felt like it was rotten."

Ambiance

Pros:

  • "A true feeling like you are having a meal in a cabin out in the woods!"
  • "Liked atmosphere, eating by the lake."
  • "It is a great view, and it was very peaceful and relaxing."
  • "Beautiful new decor!"
  • "Indoor is really nicely decorated restaurant and bar."
  • "The decor was very welcoming even from the outside."
  • "The restaurant and bar has a very comfortable ambiance- country lake house meets modern farmhouse."

Cons:

  • "It was chilly inside so left our jackets on."
  • "The place wasn't packed and there was no line so 600 reviews doesn't mean squat."
  • "Parking lot is too small."
  • "The noise level was so high that my wife and I couldn't carry on a conversation."
  • "There were a quite a few flies which was the only draw back."
  • "It's way too cold and loud."
  • "Probably not the place for hikers to eat."

Value

Pros:

  • "Amazing for the price."
  • "Food was amazing, service was very friendly and prices are very reasonable."
  • "The food was absolutely incredible. Gourmet food at a reasonable price."
  • "Creative recipes, great flavor, prepared well, and extremely reasonable prices."
  • "Worth the price: me and my boyfriend split it and enjoyed it."
  • "Food was really good, servings are big, and very affordable."
  • "The food is excellent! I had the grilled salmon with pea puree, barley and roasted brussel sprouts, and it was the best salmon dish ever."

Cons:

  • "The house salads were good but too small for $12 each."
  • "Careful ordering soft drinks. They charge $3 for each one. No refills."
  • "I think the full dinner selections were a bit on the high side $12 for a Kale salad and additional $4 for chicken is steep."
  • "Not expensive, but since portions and food sucked, not worth it one bit."
  • "Portions not great for those prices."
  • "Delicious, but pricey, at $11.00."
  • "Kind of pricey too for what it was."

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.